Revenge of the Simulwatch!

Non Non Biyori wasn't an entirely serious suggestion, though I'd be absolutely fine with doing a simulwatch of it. I think we had a discussion earlier about those kinds of shows sometimes being difficult to talk about on an episode by episode basis. Not necessarily because there's nothing to say, more that it can be difficult to put what you get out of the experience into words. I think that also ties into the point about people having difficulty recommending Non Non Biyori, the problem isn't that there's anything wrong with the show just that it can be hard enough to express why you like it and potentially even more difficult to judge how someone else might like it.

Though Slice of Life is a fairly wide genre (is it a genre? I think we had that discussion too, once), I'd absolutely say that Non Non Biyori is one of the best. I don't often commit to that kind of thing but I'd do it for Non Non Biyori. I think if you have an interest in the genre at all then chances are very good that you'll get something out of Non Non Biyori.

As for having to be in a specific mood, I don't really think that's the case. Maybe it's because I'm the "specific person" if that's a thing but I suspect I could watch Non Non Biyori at any time. I mentioned that I'd do a simulwatch if people wanted to and that's true despite the fact that I finished re-watching both seasons just recently. That was re-watching it shortly after having watched the simulcast of the new season, prior to which I re-watched the first season. I'm probably a bad example compared to most people but I don't find it difficult to be in the mood for Non Non Biyori. That said, it's likely I'm one of the people that made comments along the lines that were mentioned, which is probably a case of me expressing myself poorly.

animefreak17 said:
Complex characters
Gorgeous animation
Beautiful music
Over the top stories
Funny
I think that'd apply pretty well to Non Non Biyori, depending on how you define "over the top stories" and possibly not counting the animation. I'm not good at judging quality of animation, though Non Non Biyori does look gorgeous anyway.

When it comes to Slice of Life shows, I'd agree that the characters are usually what draws you in and makes the experience worthwhile. It's basically like spending time with people that you might find fun, interesting or whatever else. People often say that these kinds of shows don't have a story or that nothing happens but really it's more the case that the stories tend to be more personal and are often subtle. Maybe they're also less likely to have a message or moral, or at least be blatant about it. I suppose they're partly called Slice of Life because it can be about studying life and that doesn't always make for easy answers.

Okay, I've probably gone on about Non Non Biyori too much. Especially since we're probably not going to be simulwatching it (this time, at least).

I did consider suggesting Space Brothers, which I think would work quite well on an episode by episode basis. As mentioned though, it's length is an issue. Some might consider it slow paced as well, although I'd say it justifies the pace by having plenty of story in each episode (apart from the three recaps, though they do fit a little bit of story in). To be fair, it's not really a complete story either, though I wouldn't say it's unsatisfying as it is. I was going to watch it with someone, which was why I didn't suggest it, but it looks like that's not going to happen now. It's maybe one to consider for the future.
 
I generally use SOL shows as a break from the more action oriented shows i mainly watch, they're just easy and relaxing to watch.

I was planning on watching Non Non Biyori soon so i'd be up for a simulwatch :)
 
Smeelia said:
I did consider suggesting Space Brothers, which I think would work quite well on an episode by episode basis. As mentioned though, it's length is an issue. Some might consider it slow paced as well, although I'd say it justifies the pace by having plenty of story in each episode (apart from the three recaps, though they do fit a little bit of story in). To be fair, it's not really a complete story either, though I wouldn't say it's unsatisfying as it is. I was going to watch it with someone, which was why I didn't suggest it, but it looks like that's not going to happen now. It's maybe one to consider for the future.

Does Space Brothers count as SOL? I thought it had far too much actual plot to count...
 
Well, I was talking about Space Brothers because you mentioned it, not specifically because it's a Slice of Life show. I suppose there's some debate about what counts as a Slice of Life show, at least I remember there was a discussion about it here previously. I thought Space Brothers was mentioned there but I can't find the relevant post so I probably imagined it.

I'd lean towards counting Space Brothers as a Slice of Life show, quite a lot of Slice of Life shows do have significant amounts of plot. The main story follows Mutta during a particular period of his life and also gives us a bit of a look into the lives of the people he encounters. Most of the episodes have their own story with most of them commenting on/observing some aspect of the lives of the people involved. Mutta has his goals and I suppose you could say there's kind of a main story but it feels that there's a lot of time spent on things that wouldn't be needed if the main story was the whole point of the show. I think one of the reasons that the show works quite well even with the main story unfinished (and taking 99 episodes to get there) is that the goal isn't really the point so much as the journey.

I don't know for sure if that makes it a Slice of Life show, maybe it's a drama or whatever with Slice of Life elements. You could argue that there is a goal that the show is ultimately aiming for and there tend to be kind of "arc" like stories so maybe that makes it less of a Slice of Life show. That said, even during those "arcs" the show tends to take time out for the characters and all sorts of little ideas that don't necessarily contribute directly towards a goal. Whatever way you define it, it does feel kind of Slice of Life like and there's enough crossover in the appeal that I think fans of Space Brothers are also likely to enjoy at least some other Slice of Life shows.

I'm not sure where the idea that there's not much plot/story in Slice of Life shows comes from. I wouldn't say it's a requirement for being a Slice of Life show. Slice of Life shows can often be about a whole experience, which might make it more difficult to pick out the specific events/moments that you thought were most important. They are perhaps also more likely to leave things unsaid, relying on the audience to notice things or decide for themselves what things mean. I guess it maybe also ties into what I said before about it sometimes being difficult to explain the shows, if you break anything down to just the events it doesn't always give the true impression of the experience.

I'm probably getting a bit too off topic. There were a couple of threads about Slice of Life shows before that might be worth digging up or we could always start a new one.
 
Professor Irony said:
Smeelia said:
Aww, no Bubblegum Crisis? I guess I'll end up watching it on my own.

I'd have been up for it (as, I'd have thought, would ayase), but I guess it was always going to be a more niche option. If you're posting about it as you go along, I'd be interested to know what you make of it anyway.
Heh, it's nice to see what I'm remembered for. Have been pretty absent from the forums recently but yeah, I can *always* watch BGC again and will be similarly interested to hear your thoughts Smeelia.
 
Hmm interesting Baccano is leading at the moment with 9 votes... the BD is out in two weeks... perhaps a good time to start should that come out on top...? Couldn't hold off watching my MCM copy in the end but I'd always be up for a re-watch of Baccano.

Obtained BGC myself recently... about half way through the series but for some reason it just doesn't seem to be resonating with me... I think perhaps I need to concentrate more and have less distractions when I go back to it.
 
I think it'd be reasonable to do a Baccano simulwatch based on the results, only 10 isn't a huge crowd but maybe some people will manage to join in along the way (and I don't think we had so many for Nadia anyway). I guess we'd have to give some time after the BD release, so maybe look at starting around the week beginning the 23rd?

It'd be interesting to know who the 10 were, I'm fairly confident Baccano was one I included anyway.

Also interesting that Outlaw Star has picked up a lot of votes, I wonder if it'd be worth doing a simulwatch of it and then the Baccano one after (that'd push the date back a little too, I think). I guess two simulwatches in a row might be a big commitment for some people, it might partly depend on how many people put down for both. I think I had votes in for the top three (third being From The New World at the moment).

I still haven't got around to watching Bubblegum Crisis, I haven't really watched much recently (much for me anyway). I might aim to start at the weekend and I should have a fair bit of time next week if I need it (although that might be eaten up with Fallout 4).
 
IncendiaryLemon said:
I voted for neither so I guess I'll be skipping out this simulwatch too :p
Maybe we'll do a Hidamari Sketch one some day, you'd have to join us for that. I guess the first season is actually due to be released by MVM so maybe it could be an actual possibility.

If it turns out that most of the people that voted for one of the other options didn't vote for the top ones then there could be enough to split into groups. I could probably find time to take part in two simulwatches at once, at a push (it's probably more the writing about stuff than the watching that's difficult).
 
I've been holding off outlaw star in the hopes AL pick up the BD rights... I could possibly be persuaded... but my brain is telling me to hold out for the chance of a BD at the moment...
 
I'd think an Outlaw Star Blu-ray release would be announced at least a little while before it was released so it'll probably be long enough that it's okay to re-watch (depending on how long you usually wait). I don't know if it would be done a lot quicker than a normal release, though maybe if they already have a lot of the rights and such worked out.

With some people having picked it up cheaply recently I'm not sure there'll be a better time for a simulwatch.
 
Back
Top