DragonBlaze67
Za Warudo
Started working through my Studio Ghibli backlog yesterday. I watched From Up on Poppy Hill yesterday and Tales of Earthsea today.
From Up on Poppy Hill - 9/10
Loved this film, always do love a good coming of age film. It's a good contrast to the standard fantasy Ghibli films. I watched the dub and found it to be really well done.
When it got to the part of the story where Umi & Shun thought they were brother and sister i was turned off abit as i felt it was going the typical soap-opera route but luckily they turned it round soon after by revealing Shun was actually the son of Umi's father Yūichirō best friend, Hiroshi.
Tales of Earthsea - 5/10
Kinda wished i watched this before From Up on Poppy Hill as i didn't like it much at all. Found it quite boring at times and didn't find the characters that interesting or if they were meant to be they weren't developed very well, an example would be Arren a prince that had a split personality, killed his father, stole his sword, ran away and then joined up with Sparrowhawk with no explanation why he killed his father and stole his sword. I found the dub to be just average for this one, no performances really stood out.
Seems i agree with most of the negative reviews for the film here as it's my least favorite Ghibli film. Luckily Goro Miyazaki learned from this and made a really good film with From Up on Poppy Hill.
My next Ghibli film will be My Neighbours the Yamadas, going into it with low expectations due to its wierd art style/animation :lol:
From Up on Poppy Hill - 9/10
Loved this film, always do love a good coming of age film. It's a good contrast to the standard fantasy Ghibli films. I watched the dub and found it to be really well done.
When it got to the part of the story where Umi & Shun thought they were brother and sister i was turned off abit as i felt it was going the typical soap-opera route but luckily they turned it round soon after by revealing Shun was actually the son of Umi's father Yūichirō best friend, Hiroshi.
Tales of Earthsea - 5/10
Kinda wished i watched this before From Up on Poppy Hill as i didn't like it much at all. Found it quite boring at times and didn't find the characters that interesting or if they were meant to be they weren't developed very well, an example would be Arren a prince that had a split personality, killed his father, stole his sword, ran away and then joined up with Sparrowhawk with no explanation why he killed his father and stole his sword. I found the dub to be just average for this one, no performances really stood out.
Seems i agree with most of the negative reviews for the film here as it's my least favorite Ghibli film. Luckily Goro Miyazaki learned from this and made a really good film with From Up on Poppy Hill.
My next Ghibli film will be My Neighbours the Yamadas, going into it with low expectations due to its wierd art style/animation :lol:
Last edited by a moderator: