I also rate purely based on my how I feel about something rather than my actual critical evaluation of it
I like that. I don't think I have any one set way to rate stuff on MAL; I just base it the "good", "very good", "great" descriptions that go alongside the numbers.
The only vaguely interesting quirk of my own ratings that I can think of off the top of my head is, coincidentally, to do with
Anthem of the Heart. I used to have it one mark higher than I do now so as to have it rated slightly above
A Silent Voice*, with which it found itself often being compared. I realised how kind of irrelevant that comparison was in the end, though, and just put them on the same mark, 9 out of 10.
*@WMD might have something to say about that.
I really enjoy Jonathan Clements work, I also own his Anime: A History book
Wow, you too?
I've got that book as well.
I've only read it the once, but I'd need to revisit it since there's so much to take in. It's fantastically well researched.
I like Clements' writing a lot, including his articles in
NEO magazine. He's really good at reading between the lines of something that an industry figure has said or written to get to the core of what they
really mean by it.
His commentary tracks on some of Manga's old DVD releases are great too.
I'll need to read the booklet that comes with the collector's edition to see if there's any clarification on it.
This is terrible, but I've read that booklet and have
no recall of the contents. I'll need to take another look at it.