Of all the criticisms Dream Theater often receive, about the only one I can generally agree with is the rather hit or miss lyrics. Over Dream Theater's almost 30 years of activity, they've only really had 3 primary writers, guitarist John Petrucci, drummer Mike Portnoy and keyboardist Kevin Moore. Sure James LaBrie and John Myung write on occasion, but between them, they've probably penned less than 10 songs over 13 albums, so I'm not sure they count. Of their writers, Portnoy has always been the strongest. Whilst Kevin Moore's writing was often
far too abstract on sometime
bordering on nonsense, and Petrucci's lyrics are often
cheesy fantasy that can be
fairly cringey, Portnoy mostly bases his songs on his real life. Weather is be any of the songs from the
Twelve Step Suite or
The Mirror, that dealt with his alcoholism battle, or
Honour Thy Father, that was pretty much a big middle finger to his step dad, his lyrics always felt like they had more weight to them than the others. Not that the other two are
terrible song writers, but I think most will agree Portnoy was the best.
Of all the songs he wrote before he quit the band around 2010, I always think the 1995 epic 'A Change of Seasons' as possibly his best. Not only did he pen the whole song, which is a rarity for Dream Theater epics, with songs like Octavarium and Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence having lyrics contributed by two or more band members, but I think it's probably the most personal song he ever wrote. If you know the story behind the lyrics, it really gives them a gut punch. The song was written about the death of Portnoy's mother, and how him learning about the phrase 'Carpe Diem', 'Seize the Day' in Latin, led him to tell his mother how much he loved her, before a freak flight accident led to her early death. Knowing this story really contextualises the lyrics, and gives them way more meaning than if you just listened to them blind. Not only are the lyrics great, but it's possibly one of the best Dream Theater songs period, being the earliest example of a song they wrote over 20 minutes in length. Although I probably do like Octavarium better on the whole, I still have a ton of love for A Change of Seasons.
What's pretty sad about it is that it showed some great potential for keyboardist Derek Sherinian, who makes his Dream Theater debut in 'A Change of Seasons'. He was only on 'A Change of Seasons' and 1997's lackluster 'Falling into Infinity' before him and the band parted ways. Makes me wonder if the studio hadn't meddled in the production of 'Falling into Infinity', leading to some turbulent times for the band, if he might have stuck around a little longer than one EP and one album.