Ayase:
Jayden helps Ethan escape, but he gets captured again and banged up, and is therefore unable to take part in the final scenes. Jayden and Madison both figure it out head to the warehouse. Madison fights Scott while Jayden saves Shaun. Finally, Jayden shoots Scott. Everybody lives happily ever after. Ethan and Shaun are reunited, Madison writes a book and goes on TV, Jayden flushes his tripto and... sees some miniature tanks or something. Everyone apart from poor Lauren, who is probably more f*cked up than ever. ;_;
Tachi:
My first ending: Jayden fights Scott, Ethan saves Shaun, Madison saves ethan. Lauren died in the caar because I accidentally went for the window rather than saving her. It wasn’t clear on what the actions would do. Ethan, Madison and shaun buy a flat together, jayden dies fighting scott and scott walks free but there’s a manhunt out for him.
Ayase:
I did really enjoy the game, and it's finally taught me left from right at the age of 25. The biggest problem I have is the fact that you can create inconsistencies while playing as Scott. It was *kinda* cleverly done, the reasons for him investigating and keeping Lauren close by still make perfect sense with hindsight; but why would he save her from drowning? Similarly, why would he save old man Kramer (and why was he even investigating Gordy in the first place)? It seems odd that you can save characters you later realise you shouldn't / wouldn't have done if you possessed the knowledge you were the killer, making any other decision irrational. Also, Scott *intentionally misleads the player with his own thoughts* at certain points. Surely there's some serious breaking of the fourth wall going on when a character knows he can't tell the player what's going on?
Tachi:
I think its very cleverly done to keep you from realising its really scott. Keeping Lauren close by makes sense – keeping an eye on her. Going to the other womans house for the fone, destroying all the evidence at his flat. I believe you’re meant to save Kramer because he’s truly sorry for scotts brother dying and has been leaving flowers for him every week. If you already know that scotts the killer then saving Kramer makes even more sense, he can blackmail Kramer and frame kramers son – hence the “investigation”. Going to kramers in the first place leads me to believe scott might actually feel sorry for Lauren. As Lauren died in m game, scott went to kill Kramer, im not sure why he’s go there when Lauren doesn’t die, maybe for putting him in the car to die anyway?
As for the Misleading the player even with thoughts. Well this guy is an ex cop, he knows how the investigation goes, so you have no hope of working it out that scotts the killer. Looking back he’s the oldest character, it sort of makes sense that the death of a characters brother happened over 30 years prior… none of the other cast would have been alive at the time.