100% agree, it pisses me off more when it's simply parts 1 & 2 of the same series! MVM I kinda cut some slack because they're a smaller company and just add their logo & BBFC to whatever art the US or AU put out.
Disagree on AL CE consistency
their CE spine design is like someone threw darts at a board overall.
Their SE's are what I'd call 'overdesigned' if that's even a word. They're designed to be consistent at the cost of aesthetic. I get why, AL want that brick and mortar shop placement and the normies to buy it.
Which is good in theory and I'm sure sounded good when they were drawing up plans originally but when you're years deep and got 100's of releases they all blend into one on the shop shelf and nothing differentiates them or makes them stand out...
I'd love to see your home made designs!
Myself I'm also no artist and also no photoshop expert, but if i was first thing I'd do is drop the film/season bar put that on the back it doesn't need to be on the spine.
Shrink the AL elephant by about 30 - 40%.
Drop the BBFC on the spine! you're a boutique label and not having it doesn't seem to hurt Arrow, Eureka, 88films in HMV, if anything they're thriving.
With that you've just freed up about 60% of you're average AL SE spine, use it to give the logo of the anime more room and the image at the top more breathing room