IncendiaryLemon
Captain Karen
School Live is an amazing show and really deserves the high sales in comparison to Charlotte.
Joshawott said:Because personally, I thought there were a number of shows that deserved to sell more yet didn't. Charlotte had a lot of potential and was visually pleasing, but I can't help but feel that said potential was completely squandered towards the end of its run.
I'd say it ultimately boils down to the fact that a lot of people watched Charlotte and many of them ended up finding it disappointing. Other shows that didn't receive the same attention have met and exceeded expectations but that doesn't necessarily seem to translate into better sales. To a lot of people, it's going to look like Charlotte is selling on hype while shows with a greater level of "quality" are doing worse or no better. People are never fond of that sort of thing.Buzz201 said:I think exactly the same, but to a much greater extent. There's something about Charlotte that's making people incredibly bitter, and I don't understand why, especially when there's monster girl shows that could be taking the blame...
This entire season has been pants, even if School-Live! was the greatest show ever, the fact I had to google which show it was says a hell of a lot.
Not to spoil but there's things you don't walk back from and Charlotte did exactly that.Buzz201 said:I think exactly the same, but to a much greater extent. There's something about Charlotte that's making people incredibly bitter, and I don't understand why, especially when there's monster girl shows that could be taking the blame...
ConanThe3rd said:Not to spoil but there's things you don't walk back from and Charlotte did exactly that.
Smeelia said:I'd say it ultimately boils down to the fact that a lot of people watched Charlotte and many of them ended up finding it disappointing. Other shows that didn't receive the same attention have met and exceeded expectations but that doesn't necessarily seem to translate into better sales. To a lot of people, it's going to look like Charlotte is selling on hype while shows with a greater level of "quality" are doing worse or no better. People are never fond of that sort of thing.
I suppose your point about Gakkou Gurashi/School Live! highlights that marketing can be as important or even more so than the actual show itself. I think most people would prefer if the "quality" of the show was the only factor in it's success but it's tough to see a way that could work.
As I understand it, the monster girl shows (presumably Monster Musume and/or Jitsu Wa Watashi Wa, not sure if there were others) have met or exceeded expectations and generally received positive comments. While they might not be for everyone, it's hard to say they haven't earned decent sales. It also seems that Jitsu Wa Watashi Wa may be selling below what many would have hoped for, though I think most people have said that it's more "good" than "great".
I'd say it's going a bit far to write off the whole season, plenty of people have found at least a few shows to enjoy. I could understand if you didn't find anything you liked but even then it's a bit much to lump every show of the season in together unless you've actually watched them all.
Plus, there was Non Non Biyori Repeat, that alone made the season worthwhile.
Buzz201 said:I think that's part of the reason people hate Aniplex, because even their bad shows have good marketing strategies, whereas everybody else relies on word of mouth. Consequently their shows, even the bad ones, tend to do reasonably well.
Rosencrantz said:Buzz201 said:I think that's part of the reason people hate Aniplex, because even their bad shows have good marketing strategies, whereas everybody else relies on word of mouth. Consequently their shows, even the bad ones, tend to do reasonably well.
Wait, people hate Aniplex because they have people that work there actually do their jobs and properly advertise their products? Maybe Anno was right about the end of Anime if other companies don't put any effort into marketing :roll:
I'd like to think it if their producers didn't have such astronomical egos and were always bragging about the work they do and that everything is going to be this big huge deal that will leave the competition in the dust and make a ton of money (while their workers are overworked, underpaid and in some cases fall ill or even die as a result of their schedules), achieve cult hit status and then proceeded to engage in stealth marketing, and charge way more for their products in foreign countries than any other competing publisher while claiming the reason for it is that it's a "superior" product that people including myself wouldn't relish every chance they have to stick it to them.
I didn't mind them too much before they started to adopt their parent companies attitude more and more and strut around like they are cock of the walk and can do anything they want with anything they can get their hands on as long as it's popular, now I really dislike them and a lot of people I know hate their pricing schemes too and general cocksure attitude. If it weren't for today's surprise announcement about the SAO soundtrack I wouldn't have though they cared even remotely about their fans, up front PR and the actual quality of their product as long as they've made their money.
So yeah I'd like to think if a company is going to act and present the kind of "for the money" attitude they do that they kind of earn their extra criticism, but personally I don't even think it's enough half the time and they get away with things that other companies never would because of their PR spin, stealth marketing and friends in entertainment news. Also ironically the way you go on about fans just liking things unconditionally for what they are I'm reasonably sure you are A-1's ideal customer lol.
BlackStrat said: