CORRECTIONS
Here is one of the posts I promised before, with suggestions for some corrections to the existing entries in our main list. This adds info provided by
@Just Passing Through and
@Shiroi Hane, and fixes some oversights on my part. Here we go.
DVD list:
Akira (Manga UK): Subtitle track contains two misspellings of character names. *Does
not apply to BD in Manga UK's 2016 Collector's Edition Triple Play, but
is repeated on DVD *Cannot verify Manga's 2011 BD version
Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence (Manga UK): Numerous translation errors in subtitles. *Cannot verify BD version
Girls Und Panzer (MVM):
Recaps aren't dubbed or fully subbed and a song is replaced.
Recaps also have video issues. *BD version recap subs are unaffected
Harlock: Space Pirate (Manga UK): Bonus disc: subtitles on Japanese extended cut of film are "semi-dubtitles" with one distracting typing error in punctuation. *Same bonus disc included with BD version
Metropolis (Sony): Various mistakes in US Theatrical subtitle track; Original Japanese Translation subtitle track is unaffected. Post-credits end card is missing.
*Eureka Films BD version includes end card [links to review by
@Just Passing Through]
Panty and Stocking with Garterbelt (Manga UK):
Missing footage.
Manga is running a recall. Occasional poor translation in subtitles. No Japanese audio for the extra "Panty & Stocking in Sanitary Box" *Cannot verify BD version
Steins;Gate (Manga UK):
One commentary track missing. The subtitle script is different on DVD and BD. The DVD version has a poorer, contradictory translation. More examples of poor translation on the DVD. Some sign subs omitted. DVD has sparsity of chapter markers: only found at start and mid-point of episodes.
The Tatami Galaxy (Beez):
Distorted opening music for one episode, possibly related to the House Of Five Leaves issue. Final subtitle on episode 11 (disc 3) does not clear, leaving it displayed throughout end credits. Dubious translation on OVA mini-episode 3? (Applies only to Beez DVD version as OVAs not included in Anime Limited BD release). Also, consistent spelling, grammar and puncuation mistakes in subtitles for extra feature "Screenwriter's interview", presumably translated from German (eg "Herr Morimi" instead of Mr Morimi or Morimi-san). *Cannot verify Anime Limited's BD version for this
Voices of a Distant Star (ADV):
No signs-only subtitle track; especially problematic given the plot. Main Japanese audio out of sync with picture; Alternate (Shinkai scratch vocal) audio track is unaffected. Subtitles are out of sync with picture. Short film "She and Her Cat" included in extras has mistake in a chapter number shown in on-screen caption.
Blu-ray list:
Harlock: Space Pirate (Manga UK): Bonus disc: subtitles on Japanese extended cut of film are "semi-dubtitles" with one distracting typing error in punctuation. *Same bonus disc included with DVD version
Journey to Agartha (Collector's Edition) (Kaze): Bonus DVD extra "The journey of Makoto Shinkai" has echoing audio on the clips of 5 Centimeters per Second.
Lucky Star (Anime Limited):
Video transfer not great and a possible player glitch with one feature. Textless Opening (TV) and Textless Ending (OVA) are missing. Single missing subtitle on two episodes.
Place Promised in Our Early Days, The / Voices of a distant Star (Anime Limited): Voices of a Distant Star (DVD disc): Error in audio options: selecting "English 5.1 with song subtitles" plays film with Japanese audio and SIGN-ONLY subtitles, as song subs only appear on the full-subtitles track. The short film "She and Her Cat" included in extras has error in on-screen caption (shifted to bottom of screen in tiny font size) on BD only; DVD is unaffected. Also has mistake in a chapter number shown in on-screen caption from ADV DVD version; applies to both BD and DVD).
Steins;Gate part 1 (Manga UK):
Minor audio issue in the Japanese soundtrack. Also, some sign subs omitted, no textless credits (all BD only). Minor audio issue in the Japanese soundtrack.