The competitive elements of a non-conversation-based service like MAL or Anime Planet are very attractive to newer fans in general, since they can 'track' their progress as a fan by the amount of content they consume. I don't think we can compete with that - and I don't personally want to, as I can't really be bothered to spend days filling in a profile and turning the hobby into a massive chore in order to make my opinion seem more valuable than that of a newcomer. But it does mean that ever since these sites sprung up, a certain type of younger fan has gravitated away from 'old fashioned' forum discussions.
R
R