Eden Lake (2008)
'Feel Good Film of the Year' is often a term you see bandied about to describe gentle, heartwarming and uplifting films, films where you come out at the end with warm fuzzies and a sense of optimism going forward. Despite how common a term this seems to be amongst film critics, I don't think I've ever heard anything called the 'Feel Bad Film of the Year', which is about the most apt description I can think of for Eden Lake. The directorial debut of James Watkins, perhaps better known for the Daniel Radcliffe chiller The Woman in Black and more recently the Black Mirror series three standout episode Shut Up and Dance, Eden Lake is about as hopeless, crushing and depressing a horror film as you are likely to find yet, despite this, is an all time favourite film of mine that I just can't help but revist, despite the unrelenting misery it portrays.
Featuring Kelly Reilly and a pre-superstar Michael Fassbender, Eden Lake is about a young couple's romantic break that goes horribly wrong when Steve (Fassbender) confronts a gang of yobs eager to disrupt their weekend. What I really love about Eden Lake is that it manages to work on two levels, and both of them are down to this really simple premise. Simply looking at the movie on a surface level, it just undeniably works as a horror. Not reliant on cheap jump scares or mass amounts of grotesque torture like some its ilk, Eden Lake instead opts to create a fantastic atmosphere and sense of dread throughout almost the entire film, created via a mix of brilliant editing and cinematography and not to mention the score. The use of violence here is also brilliant in its restraint, feeling very viceral and real, but rarely actually showing much in the way of gore, cutting around the worst of it to let your imagination fill in the blanks.
Characters are are also a surprising strong point in Eden Lake, with the hateable gang of youths showing some shades of morality and remorse, and even managing to get the audience to generate a slither of sympathy for them in the gut wrenching final sequence, which I dare not spoil here, but will sit with you for days afterwards.
Where the film gets really interesting, at least to me anyway, is when you start to dig into the deeper themes it has to offer, working quite well at conveying a theme about the cyclical nature of abuse. Now, if you were to cast a cursory glance at the plot and take a surface level reading, you could easily be forgiven for thinking the actual message is something along the lines of 'the working class are all terrible', and it's one of the biggest missteps Eden Lake makes, the lack of a balanced portrayal. Having the two protagonists be upper-middle class was a bit of a mistake, as although it works well to convey a sense of culture shock, it ultimately gives off a message of 'Us vs Them', depicting literally every working class character as either an active criminal or at least complicit in crime in general, and I honestly don't think this is intentional, as the previously mentioned theme of abuse makes a lot more sense once you do some digging. The leader of the gang, Brett, is clearly abused by his father, and this translates to his psychotic behavior we see in the film, which leads him into forcing his friends to commit violent acts on Steve, leading Jenny to seek revenge, killing two kids in the process. It's easy to overlook this reading for a more political, class based one, but this feels more unintentional, masking the real meaning of the film.
If you're a horror fan, I'd consider Eden Lake to be a must watch. It's dark, intense, shocking and very bleak, but it has a crystal clear message behind it, and doesn't do anything just for the sake of shock, making it one of my all time favourites.