Halloween (2007)
With the newest attempt at reviving the never-ending Halloween franchise arriving in cinemas this October, it occured to me that I never checked out the last attempt at a reboot, which was Rob Zombie's Halloween from 2007. I'd always heard mixed things about this one, as it seemed rather polarizing, and after watching it, I can't help but feel that I'm somewhat on the fence myself.
The most glaring and obvious issue with this film is the fact that it wasn't content with being a simple remake of the 1978 cult classic, but instead a prequel/remake hybrid. Michael Myers, at least in the original, was a total force of nature, a psychopath with totally unknown motivations and whose past is shrouded in secrecy, and this is essential to what makes him scary. You don't know who he is or why he's doing what he's doing, but he can't be stopped. This remake seems to stomp all over this notion by dedicating the entire first half reveal the history of the character, and even try and generate sympathy for the maniac by showing his tragic upbringing, a mix of an abusive step father, stripper mother, uncaring sister and undiagnosed and untreated mental illness. Not only is it totally unnecessary to show all this, it strips the character, at least in part, of what makes him scary. It gives emotions and feelings to what is supposed to be an unstoppable killing machine. I'm not entirely sure what Rob Zombie's intent was with taking the character in this direction, but it sure didn't work very well.
What could have mitigated this was if the backstory bit was far shorter than what it ends up being in the final cut. At a little under 2 hours in length, there are great chunks that could have been lifted from this to get it down to a leaner, meaner running time, especially from the start. Outside of Michael killing his sister and step-father, there isn't a whole lot that really needed to be here, such as him killing the bully, his sister's sex scene, and most of the metal hospital scenes before the flash forward. The less they show of Michael's childhood, the better, and if you edited this film down to ~90 minutes or so, it'd have been a lot better for it.
Lastly, there is the use of John Carpenter's original score within this film which, whilst good intentioned, doesn't work well at all. It just isn't suited to the tone or visuals at all, and feels crowbarred in to evoke a sense of nostalgia of familiarity amongst the audience, which is a pretty cheap way of trying to people like your film.
Although at this point it may sound like I wasn't a fan of Halloween, I actually still enjoyed it quite a bit, in spite of its flaws. A lot of this can be directly attributed to the musician-turned-director at the helm, Rob Zombie. His grunge aesthetic, carried over from his music, is a rather unique one amongst horror directors, and it is abundantly clear the he had a clear vision in mind of the kind of Halloween movie he wanted to make, and he executed it very well. At this point in time, the franchise was a laughing stock, losing credibility with every sequel, and becoming increasingly absurd to boot, so handing the reins over to an auteur such as Zombie to give a totally new and fresh take on the decades old series was the shot in the arm it needed. Zombie, as a filmmaker, is just as polarizing as the film itself, but I do love it when you can tell who directed a film just by watching it, and this is certainly achieved here.
Given the gore-heavy horror films were in vogue around the time this film was produced, it's no surprise that this is the most violent and gory franchise entry to date, which is something I can get behind. I do love a good splatterfest, and in this regard, Halloween delivers in spades. There's nothing too creative, mostly just stabbings and slashings, but it all feels very viceral and effective. Nothing feels over the top, showing a surprising amount of self-restraint in places, especially given it's peers at the time such as Hostel and Saw.
Overall, it isn't hard to see why fans and non-fans alike are so split on this particular film. It has a lot of strengths, but at the same time, is undermined by an overlong running time and too much backstory. I wouldn't go so far to call Halloween (2007) a good movie, but nonetheless, I still enjoyed it.