Attack on Titan: Season One
Very big spoilers in tags, statements that may hint at giving stuff away not. You have been warned (though I imagine I was the last person here yet to watch this anyway).
-----
After watching episode 4 of Attack on Titan, I had one thought:
"I want to see more of Annie."
Boy did I get my wish, though not quite in the way I expected. But then there wasn't much in Attack on Titan that
did go the way I expected. This show is an absolute master-class in how to keep the audience on the edge of their seat, screw with their expectations and why too much foreshadowing is for losers. Most of the twists and revelations were genuinely shocking on a level I haven't seen since Death Note and I'd say AoT probably surpasses it. While they could have done a bit more to
make best girl titan look y'know, a bit less like best girl so it wasn't quite so obvious, things like
the double-whammy of Eren's fake-out death and the subsequent revelation he was the "friendly" titan and the revelations that
Eren and Mikasa had stabbed her parents' murderers to death as kids, that
there are people in other intelligent titans and especially that
THERE ARE TITANS IN THE FRIGGIN' WALLS all had me at least raising my eybrows, at best dropping my jaw.
Something the show does astoundingly well is to progress the plot and answer just enough of the audience's questions (some of which they probably hadn't even asked because they didn't know there was a question in the first place) that the pace never seems slow, while raising even more questions for them to think about. Hell, an entire season down and we still don't know
what's in Eren's basement and that was a question raised
in the very first episode. And I don't even
care that I still don't know, because the barrage of new information about the world and the titans has been coming in so thick and fast for the rest of the series that it never gave me time to dwell on it or become impatient.
The action is incredibly tense as well, because you know that no-one is safe. More than once I suspected characters were done for only for them to scrape a victory or escape, other times I thought a character had it in the bag only for them to get pulped seconds later. And that leaves you feeling quite on edge for the characters, at least the characters you care about. And that brings me to my only real criticism of the show - I didn't feel like I knew anywhere near enough about anyone other than Eren, Armin and Jean to particularly care about them, with most of the cast's characters and personalties being defined by one-note quirks. Even Mikasa, who we at least get to see a tragic back-story for, still comes across as fairly under-developed beyond being Eren's childhood friend who exists simply to protect him (because he protected her once) and potentially develop into his love interest. Armin and Jean get some pretty great development, better than Eren even (who is a pretty straightforward guy to understand) but most of the other characters can be summed up in a single sentence like "the girl who eats a lot" "the unsure guy" "the cute girl" or "the tough girl". And that strikes me as pretty woeful after spending 25 episodes with these characters. A major reason I
did want to see more of Annie was because she had some intriguing things to say - I got the sense she had opinions and beliefs about the world and society that she was just barely holding back, and I still hold out hope for the future that I'm going to find out more about them.
Still, for the fantastic and mysterious story that still has me gripped for future instalments and the well realised and relatively unique world, Attack on Titan still deserves a solid 8.8/10 by my reckoning.