Oreimo Season 2 - Eps 9 - 16
Well that didn't end nearly as badly as I was perhaps expecting, and was pretty enjoyable for the most part.
I can see why it's disliked though At the end of Ep12 I was surprised to see an Anime character actually give a serious a direct response to a confession of love. Trouble is they continued this for every potential match (plus Kaneko who I'm not convinced spent enough time with Kyosuke to be on the confession of love list). Then they turn around and break off the relationship because they'd agreed it was a limited time affair.
I suppose this could be a jab at the fandom, most shows end with an undecided main character and 4-5 girls jostling for him. This time an end is put to everything and whichever girl you might of been rooting for lost.