Yeah, Yiggybean actually put out a statement yesterday saying they refuse to stock it. The vast majority of comments under the Seven Seas announcement appear to be negative, and the vast majority of ones on the Yiggybean thing are lauding them for their stance.Kinda surprised it has taken this long for SS to break into Thai novels / comics, as I know there is a lot of popular BL that comes from there. Unfortunately with KinnPorsche, there seems to be some kind of controversy surrounding the author (I gather from the comments) so that's not such a great starting point.
Yeah, Yiggybean actually put out a statement yesterday saying they refuse to stock it. The vast majority of comments under the Seven Seas announcement appear to be negative, and the vast majority of ones on the Yiggybean thing are lauding them for their stance.
Seven Seas really need to think about these things when they're choosing what to license, something similar happened a while ago with the Danmei 'You've Got Mail'. Whether it will have an appreciable impact on the sales remains to be seen since neither of them are out yet.
I meant in the sense that when Seven Seas announced the 'You've Got Mail' license last year it got a very similar reaction in comments (incientally Yiggybean mentioned in comments they won't be stocking that either). I don't know anything about pre-existing discussions elsewhere because I'm not really immersed in those spaces.Was the You've Got Mail situation similar in that it happened a while ago? I know with this new one there's discussion going dating back to mid-2022, certainly enough time to decide not to continue with the licensing process.
I meant in the sense that when Seven Seas announced the 'You've Got Mail' license last year it got a very similar reaction in comments (incientally Yiggybean mentioned in comments they won't be stocking that either). I don't know anything about pre-existing discussions elsewhere because I'm not really immersed in those spaces.
But given the sheer number of people pointing this stuff out to them immediately, they have on both occasions had every opportunity during the licensing process to look into what the opinions on the authors were before finalising everything. The fact they either didn't care to look or looked and decided to do it anyway doesn't make them look so good.
Absolutely!I definitely feel sorry for the translator and other staff involved who are likely getting hate for no reason.
The illustrator who had their Twitter linked in the announcement post put out a tweet saying they were being overwhelmed and that had they known any of this stuff about the author they wouldn't have taken the job in the first place.I definitely feel sorry for the translator and other staff involved who are likely getting hate for no reason.
I've been baffled by their licensing decisions a few times in the past lol, although obviously not stuff with a huge controversy around it. A few months ago they chose to license a yuri series that had one volume, hadn't had new chapters for years, and had been effectively cancelled with no ending. That definitely had absolutely nothing to do with the surveys.I find it a little difficult to understand when the publisher runs a monthly request questionnaire in which readers can ask for the titles they'd like them to license,
That is, indeed, very perplexing and hard to explain. Although... it's probably different now but in earlier manga publishing days (much earlier!) I do seem to recall being told that US or European publishers would be offered a bundle of titles, meaning that if they wanted one title in particular, they'd also have to take on-board several others to ensure they got 'the one' they wanted.I've had similar thoughts about one or two of the yuri series they've licensed previously lol. A few months ago they chose to license a series that had one volume, hadn't had new chapters for years, and had been effectively cancelled with no ending. That definitely had absolutely nothing to do with the surveys.