Top 10 anime of all time! (2014 vote)

[Morbo]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

1. FMA Brotherhood (10)
2. Lucky Star(9)
3. Dragonball (original not Z) (8)
4. Ano Hana (7)
5. Gintama(6)
6. Death Note (5)
7. Clannad After Story (4)
8. Steins Gate (3)
9. Mushishi (2)
10. Rurouni Kenshin (1)

[EDIT] removed movies, sorry didn't fully read the opening post as I was at work.

 

[BanzaiJedi]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (10)
Lucky Star (9)
Psycho-Pass (8)
Time of Eve (7)
Cowboy Bebop (6)
Garden of Sinners (5)
Monogatari (4)
Chihayafuru (3)
Neon Genesis Evangelion (2)
Initial D (1)

EDIT: Amended. Movies removed.

 

[devilrules666]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Hey guys it's tv shows only. No movies so is it ok if you guys change your top 10? Sorry for the trouble but we can't conpare movies to tv shows!

 

[devilrules666]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Sorry for the double post. I consider a film series like garden of sinners to be able to get in as well as ovas series. But single movies no

 

[Joshawott]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Wait, I actually have to rank them in order of preference too? That's too mean! Okay, let me try (and most likely end up disagreeing with my list a week later xD). Also, surely if film and OVA series' are included but singular films aren't, that really confuses things? Might it not be a better idea to simply have a separate list Movies/OVAs?

Anyway, here's my TV anime list:

1. Fate/Zero (10 Points).
2. Puella Magi Madoka Magica (9 Points).
3. Toradora (8 Points).
4. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (7 Points).
5. K-ON! (6 Points).
6. Outlaw Star (5 Points).
7. Cowboy Bebop (4 Points).
8. Nisekoi (3 Points)
9. Sound of the Sky (2 Points).
10. Usagi Drop (1 Point).

And because I like torturing myself, here is my Top 10 Feature Length Anime List, in case we decide to do one of those as well:

1. Wolf Children (10 Points).
2. The Wind Rises (9 Points).
3. The Cat Returns (8 Points).
4. Puella Magi Madoka Magica The Movie Part 1 - Beginnings (7 Points).
5. Whisper of the Heart (6 Points).
6. K-ON! The Movie (5 Points).
7. Kiki's Delivery Service (4 Points).
8. Grave of the Fireflies (3 Points).
9. The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya (2 Point).
10. Mardock Scramble: The First Compression (1 Points).

 

[devilrules666]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

We can do a film afterwards! That is a great idea. Yeah I just can't compare films to series because for me a film hasn't got as much time to tell a story as a tv series. Sorry for the mind **** this has caused

 

[mangaman74]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

1. Aria (10)
2. Cowboy Bebop (9)
3. Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood (8)
4. Gunbuster (7)
5. Giant Robo (6)
6. Black Lagoon (5)
7. Baccano (4)
8. Code Geass (3)
9. K-On (2)
10. Steins;Gate (1)

This has been tough. The first 6 or 7 are a given (although not necessarily the order). The other places I had around 10 to 15 shows to choose from (no room for Durarara, Escaflowne, El-Hazard or Haruhi for instance).

 

[Wakey]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

1. Higurashi (10 Points)
2. Fight Ippatsu! Juuden-chan!! (9 Points)
3. Madoka Magica (8 Points)
4. Yuru Yuri (7 Points)
5. Steins;gate (6 Points)
6. Oreimo (5 Points)
7. Welcome to the NHK (4 Points)
8. Watamote (3 Points)
9. Shiki (2 Points)
10. Black lagoon (1 Point)

 

[devilrules666]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Update!

1. Cowboy Bebop 56 Points
2. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 51 Points
3. Steins Gate 50 Points]
4. Madoka Magica 49 Points
5. Code Geass 35 Points
6. Baccano 29 Points
7. Fate\Zero 29 Points
8. Higurashi 29 Points
9. Evangelion 28 Points
10 Harui Suzimaya 20 Points

 

[Ian Wolf]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

1. Gurren Lagann (10 points)
2. Clannad / Clannad After Story (9 points)
3. Ouran High School Host Club (8 points)
4. Aria (7 points)
5. K-On! (6 points)
6. One Piece (5 points)
7. Astro Boy (4 points)
8. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (3 points)
9. Hetalia: Axis Powers (2 points)
10. Neon Genesis Evangelion (1 point)

 

[black1blade]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

First post. To be honest I don't really like ranking thinkgs but if I have to:
1.The garden of sinners (10 points)
2.higurashi (9 points)
3.Code geass (8 points)
4.FMAB (7 points)
5.GITS (6 points)
6.Haruhi (5 points)
7.Baccano (4 points)
8.Fate zero (3 points)
9.Monster (2 points)
10.Clannad (1 point)

 

[Orgun]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

This is an almost impossible task, I've changed this list a dozen times and I'm still not entirely happy with the bottom 5 but as it stands for now:

Detonator Orgun (10)
Mobile Suit Z Gundam (9)
Heavy Metal L-Gaim (8)
Armored Trooper Votoms (7)
Eureka Seven (6)
Knights of Sidonia (5)
Mobile Suit Gundam: The 08th MS Team (4)
Cowboy Bebop (3)
GitS SAC 2nd Gig (2)
Neon Genesis Evangelion (1)

 

[Vashdaman]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

1. Trigun 10
2. Glasslip 9
3. My Little Monster 8
4. Samurai X Trust/Betrayal 7
5. Samurai Champloo 6
6.Cowboy Bebop 5
7. Dragon Ball Z 4
8. Yu Gi Oh 3
9. School Rumble 2
10. Natsume rendezvous 1

Genuinely surprised Natume Rendezvous made my list. And it didn't even make Rui's.

Edit: Sorry it did make Rui's, after all. The world hasn't gone completely mad yet.

Edit 2: Actually no, it really didn't, that's a different anime with Natsume in the title! The world has gone completely mad! Either that, or I have.

Edit 3: So it's called Naksuyuki Rendezvous, not Natsume Rndezvous.

Edit 4: I'm not high or drunk, I promise. Just tired. This post has ended up a bit like that answer machine scene in the film Swingers.

 

[bored0stiff]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Ok, this took a lot of arguing, and I'm sure I'll change my mind in like 10 minutes - but I'll stick with what I come up with now:

1. Steins Gate (10)
2. Death Note (9)
3. Kill La Kill (8)
4. K-On (7)
5. Madoka Magica (6)
6. Attack on Titan (5)
7. Kotoura-San (4)
8. Nichijou (3)
9. No Game No Life (2)
10. Chobits (1) (Nostalgia reasons! If I hadn't have stumbled upon it when I was 11 - I might never have got into anime)

 

[Agent-347]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

► My vote:
Just like some others I have trouble giving an order to my lists, but after some fiddling I came with one I find okay to publish.

01. Angel Beats! - 10 points
02. Clannad (franchise) - 9 points
03. Black Rock Shooter - 8 points
04. TsukuYomi Moon Phase - 7 points
05. School Rumble (franchise) - 6 points
06. The Tower of Druaga - 5 points
07. Tari Tari - 4 points
08. Needless - 3 points
09. Vandread - 2 points
10. Dance in the Vampire Bund - 1 point

By the way, shouldn't we all agree the best anime of all time is actually Schoolgirl Milky Crisis? Let's give it 1,000,000 points. =P

Nota bene: with "franchise" I mean I can't pick one or the other season or split them. Clannad and School Rumble as a whole are awesome.

► Tally:
I felt like doing some QC for some odd reason and I am pretty sure Devilrules666 made a few mistakes when tallying up the points (or I'm lacking insight in the logic, but I doubt that).
I'm not saying I didn't make any mistakes myself though. ^_^; I'm for convenience sake releasing my tally of everything that got 10 or more points just to attempt to be of help.

Place 1 through 10:
68 Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood
64 Cowboy Bebop
63 Steins;Gate
53 Puella Magi Madoka Magica
43 Code Geass
38 Higurashi (When They Cry)
37 Clannad (+ After Story)
33 Baccano
32 Fate/Zero
30 Neon Genesis Evangelion
Place 11 through 20:
28 The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
27 Death Note
22 Black Lagoon
21 K-On
18 Lucky Star
18 Ouran High School Host Club
17 Aria
17 Natsume Yuujinchou
16 Angel Beats
16 Trigun
Place 21 through 30:
15 Garden of Sinners
15 Moribito
15 One Piece
15 Spice and Wolf
14 My Little Monster
13 Attack on Titan
12 Eden of the East
12 Last Exile
12 Mawaru Penguindrum
12 Shiki
Place 31 through 44:
12 Welcome to the NHK
11 Giant Robo
11 xxxHOLIC
10 Air Gear
10 Detonator Orgun
10 Gunbuster
10 Macross
10 Monster
10 Nana
10 Nodame Cantabile
10 Revolutionary Girl Utena
10 Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
10 Tiger and Bunny
10 Toradora

 

[devilrules666]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Update!

1. Cowboy Bebop 64 points
2. Steins Gate 60 points
3. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 58 points
4. Madoka Magica 55 points
5. Code Geass 43 points
6. Higurashi 38 points
7.Baccano 33 Points
8. Clannad 33 points
9. Fate/Zero 32 points
10. Evangelion 30 points

This is how I see the points. I have been writing down every vote so I don't think I have missed anything. But like you said no one is perfect. I am pretty sure I haven't made a mistake

 

[jonno394]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Hi Devils, check the votes between your Wed Oct 22, 2014 1:09 pm update and Thu Oct 23, 2014 10:50 am update.

Your tally for FMA:B doesnt tally up properly with the votes cast inbetween.

 

[Agent-347]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

I am pretty sure I haven't made a mistake

Willing to bet £1000 on it you have mistakes on yours? I don't have that money, but I'm for once overly confident that I'm right about you having made at least one mistake.

I don't see the point of you wanting to do this if you aren't going to at least tally 3 times to be sure you haven't made mistakes. I did simply one round of QC and my result is different.
I mean, are we going to complain about the QC of the anime industry when we can't even QC a simple survey?! Isn't that hypocrisy?
Plus the goal of a survey is a correct representation of the public's thoughts, it wouldn't be such a big deal if the top 10 was the same in your result as in mine. But it isn't. #OCD

Allow me to quote all votes for a certain series to back up my tally. No need to quote Cowboy Bebop, Code Geass, Higurashi (When They Cry), Baccano, Fate/Zero and Neon Genesis Evangelion because we agree on those. ^_^
It's nothing personal. If it was Rui, Mangaranga, NormanicGrav, Arbalest or even Andrew Partridge doing this I'd also make word of there being something wrong.

4. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (7 points)

2. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (9 points)

3. FMA BH

9. FMA B (2 Points)

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 10

1. FMA Brotherhood (10)

4. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (7 Points).

3. Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood (8)

4.FMAB (7 points)

7 + 9 + 8 + 2 + 10 + 10 + 7 + 8 + 7 = 68

2. Steins Gate (9 points)

5. Steins;Gate (6 points)

7. Steins;Gate (4 points)

Steins;Gate (9)

2. Steins Gate (9)

Steins;Gate - 2

Steins; Gate 4

8. Steins Gate (3)

10. Steins;Gate (1)

5. Steins;gate (6 Points)

1. Steins Gate (10)

9 + 6 + 4 + 9 + 9 + 2 + 4 + 3 + 1 + 6 + 10 = 63

9. Madoka Magica (2 points)

2. Madoka Magica (9 points)

8. Puella Magi Madoka Magica (3 points)

5. Madoka Magica (6)

1. Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica (10 points)

2. Puella Magi Madoka Magica (9 Points).

3. Madoka Magica (8 Points)

5. Madoka Magica (6)

2 + 9 + 3 + 6 + 10 + 9 + 8 + 6 = 53

4. Clannad (7 points)

4. Clannad After Story (7 points)

7. Clannad After Story (4)

2. Clannad / Clannad After Story (9 points)

10.Clannad (1 point)

02. Clannad (franchise) - 9 points

7 + 7 + 4 + 9 + 1 + 9 = 37

 

[jonno394]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

Agent, you've missed out durarara in your overall list......no-ones perfect I guess

edit - unless you're not including anything with less than 10 points in your tally?

 

[VoxPhantom]

Re: Top 10 anime of all time!

I'd have thought harder about my choices if I'd known this was going to be such serious business.