mangaman74
Akatsuki
MercenaryRaiden said:mangaman74 said:The fact that Man Utd's first goal today was a penalty which resulted in a red card for QPR when the Man Utd player was offside shows that the standard of officals is as poor in the Premier League as it is in the lower leagues. I watched the Reading vs Leeds match the other day on TV and Leeds could (and should) have had 3 players sent off as opposed to the 1 player that did get a red card (the worst challenge was by Danny Pugh).
I think this week specifically has really shown off the level of ineptness of officials, although this could be because my club were in the middle of it. I don't want to quickly blame the refs though, because whilst shocking I've noticed far more time and time again that the linesmen are actually more at fault. Not for actually calling wrong offside decisions, but because they don't have the spines to actually MAKE decisions. Far too often I see them wait for the referees decision before raising their flags. I think Ref's need some protection yes, but I feel that they vastly need more help from their other officials because linesmen do such a poor job at the moment.
The Newcastle vs Liverpool match also saw a poor linesman's decision. While it was nil-nil a Newcastle player cleared a goalbound shot off the line with his arm and avoided giving away a penalty and getting sent off. The linesman had a clear view of it as it was on his side of the pitch with no other players in his line of sight.
On the other hand not all poor decisions are the fault of linesmen as some referees prefer to make all the decisions (they like to be the centre of attention) which is why you sometimes see linesmen follow the referees decision rather than make the decision themselves.