Gender roles, men + women, equal rights: discuss it all here

Liquid Skin

Magical Girl
Ok, one long deviation from the chav thread later and this thing is born.

Just looking for some good discussion here peeps. What are your opinions of equal rights between men and women? How far do you think we should take it? What does it mean to be a man or woman in today's soceity and how do you define yourself accordingly?

More and more we're seeing law suits etc being filed by women for unequal pay and rights in the workplace but i want to broaden the perspective. Do you think the two genders are equal in their private life's? In the public view? Between friends?

Ok, far too many questions, ill shut up now.

:D
 
Otaku-san said:
If your white & male, you get sweet FA

same if your honest & hardworking

second that motion. (and blames imigrants)

i remember a convo in the office that a secretary sued her boss as she developed RSI (Repetitive strain injury) because she had to use a keyboard and won the case, got her a few thousand pounds aswell :(

*currently looking for the story online*
 
I don't feel equality is 100% there yet (though it's certainly improved a lot from even a century ago - I don't think I could have lived with myself if I had been born then!).

From the previous thread, I also don't personally think men are peer pressured to punch one another and hang out at pubs any more than women are to buy shoes and vomit out their dinner each night to be "attractive" - some succumb to the peer pressure, some don't, but it's probably as rotten for both sets of us.

Also not sure it can be proven that women have a lower threshold for pain ;) it could easily be that men, driven more by testosterone and the instincts and social conditioning to win, see the pain's warning as something to be ignored with the goal in sight. Whereas a woman, driven by social conditioning to be responsible and nurturing, might judge that say, losing a limb just to be king of the hill isn't worth it. I've seen no evidence that any men I know hurt any differently than I do. Maybe they also just feel more peer pressure to hide it when they do? Never been terribly bothered by peer pressure myself.

On the media circus and reports of women earning less or not being able to do certain things, it's wrong to limit what females can achieve on the premise that they might have children; many don't. I have no problem with earning less than an equivalently skilled single man if I am dividing my responsibility with having children (even after the birthing stage, there are times when you have to pick the children or the job, and for me I'd always pick the first so I accept that I'm not qualified to be a serious careerwoman in this respect). If there were no children, it would be a problem to me that someone's gender is a limitation on their potential. Similarly if the man was a primary caregiver for children of his own he should be treated the same way a mother is, for better and for worse.

To go off on a rambling tangent (sorry), when I play online games, I often play as a male character. I avoid all of the scary nutcases who chase female characters around giving them presents and asking for their contact details. But more deeply than that, the way I'm treated by some players who don't know I play both is different when I log on as a male character and a female, even if it's the same character type. If I play as a male rogue, people just expect me to get on with my job and stab things, excellent. If I play as a female, there seems to be some weird undercurrent where people are impressed I can actually hold a mouse and my skill in the group is in question unless I play far better than they expect; people keep trying to help me play or dive in front of monsters to protect me. If I beat them in a contest, some people actually exclaim that they are ashamed they lost to a girl. They should be ashamed but that's because I'm not very good, not because I don't have a penis. I don't see how my gender relates to my ability to buttonmash.

I know an awful lot of people of both genders deliberately play as girl characters to get an easy ride by milking these prejudices (which then reinforces them!) so it's never going to stop unless there's a cultural shift to stop treating women like people of a different, less capable species. Sometimes I just want to stab virtual monsters, not prove myself worthy to be there in the first place.

Irrelevantly this forum name was chosen for its ambiguous (in Japan...) gender connotations too for similar reasons :)

I see physical gender as mostly irrelevant unless I want to have sex with the person - much like homosexuality, to drag up an older thread. As I don't tend to want to have sex with people I meet, it's generally ignorable in favour of their other individual strengths and weaknesses. If some people want to act in a "girly" way and some want to be "manly" that's fine, but they won't get any special treatment either way!

R
 
Well, if it's between the male/female stuff, then it SHOULD be equal, with some exceptions for that sex (i.e. maturnity leave for women). Some things cant be avoided, but in such a capitalist world here, we can get anything for the most pathetic excuse.

I feel we need to cut off the red tape that seems to string along these small cases that just takeup time/money for a friggin trip etc. Sure, if you've broken a bone or you're hurt by someone's error, then you have an excuse.

Anyways, this equal pay crap should just be sorted, so there's no need for these claims. If the person comes in 9-5, male or female, and they work hard at it, who gives a crap? They're both humans. Even the age thing gets pointless to me, i.e. up to 18 = £4-odd, where a 21+ gets £5+.

People just cant live simple lives, they just have to nit-pick at everything. That's how all this is in such a mess.
 
i love it when Rui gets going lol

the pay really isnt a problem anymore in the workplace (in a respectable job that is, if you feel your getting less money while your doing the same job as someone of the other sex and they have more pay than you then you could take it down the "sexual disgrimination" road. in this day and age if you shout discrimination loud enough you'll get some kind of benefit from it -_- )

the pay should be relevant to the work expectations.
theres jobs (like mine) that are put into bandings, which apply to all, sex holds no difference.
band 2 = £6.49 per hour
band 3 = £7.01 per hour
ect ect

then theres the jobs which are based on commission,
so the "you get what you sell" sort of mentality.
that could lead to arguements over the overall payment and there's a possibility that gender could differentiate the pay

example:
woman gets 50 people to take her survey
man gets 50 people to take his survey

woman recieves £2 per person
man recieves £2.50 per person

then theres the jobs which are completely messed up.
where the boss pays someone more money as they are a certain sex and take into account things which have nothing to do with the job specifications, boob size, how muscley, ect ect
they get paid more for the bosses personal preferences.
 
I've personally never understood why there has been inequalities between men and women at all, since in all fairness we're just as good, or as bad in some cases as one another when it comes to most things. When it comes to work, i think where i worked, we all got equal pay, but i never checked so i can't be entirely sure about that, but everyone was treated the same, and that is how it should be.

On the Online gaming side of things, if and when i do play online, i do use both male and female characters(me being male), and it can be funny how completely differently your treated as both. On my female character, some people don't always think i'm that good, but then get a huge surprise when i do a said task fairly easily, but on the male character maybe doing the exact same task, i'm just expected to do it with ease anyway, its fairly annoying.
 
Thinks like attractiveness are a double edged sword I guess - one manager might give you perks for having big boobs or sexy stubble, but another might envy you and treat you worse for it. Those things at least can be hidden or compensated for a little more easily than your biological gender though.

I think the problem with wages isn't so much pay grades - most companies which have a formal structure like this are local governments and other national institutions and honestly, those are pretty fair, at least the ones I've worked in before. It's usually private companies where women might be sneakily overlooked for promotions or flat out not hired at all due to their capacity for potential childbearing or prejudice on the employer's part, thinking they won't be as good as a man would. Of course there's some of that the other way as well - a lot of business men don't want a male secretary even if they have the skill - but studies allegedly show that on the whole, women in this country are losing out more to this kind of behaviour.

It's not just sex too; at one job I had the temporary workers were paid 50p more per hour for having a degree of any kind, even if they were less skilled or experienced than the same employees without a degree. People who had a degree in the educational equivalent of flower arranging were being paid more to do a clerical job than in some cases, their senior colleagues who had more responsibilities. Of course as a result, it was all of the people from poorer backgrounds who were being paid less no matter how hard they worked at it.

Anyway agree with Chaz's last post more or less :)

R
 
Rui said:
It's not just sex too; at one job I had the temporary workers were paid 50p more per hour for having a degree of any kind, even if they were less skilled or experienced than the same employees without a degree. People who had a degree in the educational equivalent of flower arranging were being paid more to do a clerical job than in some cases, their senior colleagues who had more responsibilities. Of course as a result, it was all of the people from poorer backgrounds who were being paid less no matter how hard they worked at it.


R

yeah i've had that too :( my last job was working for the I.T department as a administrator at band 2. my friend richard was paid band 3 merely because he went to uni and got a business degree and the boss had a crush on him. business and marketing has sod all to do with I.T :(

(altho im a certified city and guilds computer technician, which was really annoying)
 
Whats peoples view on the 'women should do the cooking and cleaning' debate :lol: This one pops up alot around here...
 
Spyro201 said:
Whats peoples view on the 'women should do the cooking and cleaning' debate :lol: This one pops up alot around here...

Whoever is the better cook does the cooking, or rather, they take it in turns, and the person who isn't that good at cooking learns to cook a bit better :p Cleaning anyone can do, it shouldn't be left to women only.
 
Arbalest said:
Spyro201 said:
Whats peoples view on the 'women should do the cooking and cleaning' debate :lol: This one pops up alot around here...

Whoever is the better cook does the cooking, or rather, they take it in turns, and the person who isn't that good at cooking learns to cook a bit better :p Cleaning anyone can do, it shouldn't be left to women only.

:thumb: consider that second by me
 
Arbalest said:
I've personally never understood why there has been inequalities between men and women at all, since in all fairness we're just as good, or as bad in some cases as one another when it comes to most things.

simple, without trying to sound sexist Women in the past were weaker than men, and back in those days, the strong ordered around the weak.

Disagree with it? there was always a chamber to behead you and bury you in and a younger person waiting in the wings.

Mankinds has come along way in the last 100 years as far as equality is concerned, but even nowerdays it's still a hard circle to break. After all, the other concept has been going on for atleast 3000 years.
 
Personally, I feel very passionately in favour of equality of the sexes. I despise the Abrahamic religions (Islam, Christianity, Judaism) for institutionalising sexism. Only men can be Catholic priests, only men can be Imams, only men can be Rabbis. It really gets to me. Woman are typically more compassionate, more understanding than men; so I think it absurd that these churches would so brazenly say "Men are superior to women. And there's nothing you can do about it".

I don't think there should be specific roles for men and women or that society should condition men to be certain things, and women to be other things.
 
No matter where this goes I think everybody should be treated equally.

I am pretty sure everywhere I have worked there has been no difference in pay scale between the genders. The only exception is normally in individual cases where reduced hours are worked (at the same hourly rate) this in my experience only because it is usually women that ask for reduced hours for family reasons.

As a single white male I tend sometimes to feel that I am being discriminated against, not through direct discrimination but by the positive discrimination applied to others. When ever overtime is required they come after the single males, because obviously the women need to get home to their families, and the single guys have nothing better to do or go home for. Also on several occasions women seemingly have been able to get away with more serious breaches of company rules than some men (who were dissaplined/dismissed), because the “sex discriminationâ€
 
CitizenGeek said:
I don't think there should be specific roles for men and women or that should society should condition men to be certain things, and women to be other things.
Yeah, I'd like to see a Rabbi raise a family without a woman beside him, and I if all women turned nuns, then the human race is screwed. XD
 
Arbalest said:
Spyro201 said:
Whats peoples view on the 'women should do the cooking and cleaning' debate :lol: This one pops up alot around here...

Whoever is the better cook does the cooking, or rather, they take it in turns, and the person who isn't that good at cooking learns to cook a bit better :p Cleaning anyone can do, it shouldn't be left to women only.


Sounds good to me :lol: Theres a guy I know who'd disagree though :lol:
 
Rui said:
If I beat them in a contest, some people actually exclaim that they are ashamed they lost to a girl. They should be ashamed but that's because I'm not very good, not because I don't have a penis. I don't see how my gender relates to my ability to buttonmash.

It's because you beat them even without the extra limb to buttonmash *coughcough*

Things will never be equal, there'll always be prejudice one way or another; say feminists 'win', or women start outnumbering men or whatever, you'd prolly find men being 'oppressed'. There's far less difference between the sexes than people think, never really gonna change since you'll always have people stereotyping.

...Man, I need to learn how to cook and sew clothing.
 
Dracos said:
When ever overtime is required they come after the single males, because obviously the women need to get home to their families, and the single guys have nothing better to do or go home for.

I work with two male colleagues with young children and I always do the overtime so they can spend time with their families and give them first choice of holiday dates so they can sync up with family trips etc. I honestly prefer it that way so their families don't miss out on time with their dads. Is this really a man/woman thing or a singles/family thing?

R
 
Lin said:
Things will never be equal, there'll always be prejudice one way or another; say feminists 'win', or women start outnumbering men or whatever, you'd prolly find men being 'oppressed'. There's far less difference between the sexes than people think, never really gonna change since you'll always have people stereotyping.

I think that's true - a lot of feminism has gone a little far and just seems to want to stamp on men as some kind of warped punishment for the injustices of the past (when the original intent, as far as I know, was just to gain equality). The way I try to live is to see everyone as humans first with their sex just being another feature like hair colour or height. As soon as any kind of gender stereotyping is put on anything it invariably ends up with one side trampled in the name of "equality".

My partner sews as I'm terrible at it :( I cook though, usually. Teamwork is definitely the way to go in dual earning households.

R
 
Back
Top