Sorry for the length, but I posted this over on another forum I use in a thread I made so it's a bit lengthy!
Game of The Year
Citizens of Earth (PS Vita via PSN) - Excellent RPG in the mould of Earthbound. Wide variety of characters, locations and quests, and with a great main storyline which is full of humour. Top notch battle system with each of the different citizens bringing something new to the table, fantastic visual style (imo) and a catchy soundtrack
Honourable mentions:
Shovel Knight (PS4) - Excellent retro style platformer. Great gameplay, brilliant soundtrack and just a whole lot of fun
Zombi (PS4) - Didn't give it a fair go on the Wii U, but loved this port. Great atmosphere.
Steins; Gate (PS Vita) - excellent plot and loads of different endings.
Dying Light (PS4) - Excellent traversal system, really enjoyable combat, and great night/day gameplay design.
Most Anticipated 2016 Title
The Legend of Zelda (Wii U) - My pick for last year as well, but seeing as this was delayed I get to choose it again! Artstyle looks great, open world will apparently be much improved compared to previous versions. DOn't know much about it, but it's Zelda, so it has to be number 1 for me!
Honourable mentions:
Ratchet and Clank (PS4) - Been waiting for this for a couple of years now. Looks like a CGI movie in action, can't wait for some 3D platforming/shooting goodness!
Yakuza 6/Nier Automata (PS4) - Grouping these together as the likelihood they'll be released in teh west next year is low, but both are hype inducing **** for me.
Cuphead (PC) - Just looks amazing in motion, old school Disney style animation.
Best game played this year released pre-2015
Mario and Luigi: SUperstar Saga (GBA) - Excellent Mario RPG, start of a rather fantastic series (all 3 could be up for this but I decided to just pick one). Charming game with catchy music, great cast of characters and excellent combat system.
Honourable Mentions:
Ys Memories of Celceta (PS Vita) - One of the best action RPG tiles I have played. Huge free roam world, addictive combat and a very good plot.
Professor Layton and The Lost Future (DS) - Best Layton story by far. Again, I could have put all 4 DS games up here as they're just great fun.
The Wolf Among Us (PS Vita) - Best Telltale game I have played. Excellent art design and soundtrack, and a damn good story with great characters to boot.