fabricatedlunatic said:
Dave said:
What does "I've heard it described as "Berserk-lite". If that's the case, I may as well spend the money on Berserk manga. Plus, Shonen Jump" mean if not an insult at claymore and shonen jump.
It means - and listen carefully as I won't explain this again - that I have heard it described as "Berserk-lite". Not by myself, by others. How are you not getting that?
As for Shonen Jump, I have never liked a single show that started life in that magazine. Not one. Combined with what I've read in reviews and blogs and forum posts, I KNOW THAT I WILL NOT LIKE CLAYMORE. Edit: Note that I am not insulting Shonen anime and manga. It has its audience and its audience is, with a few exceptions, not me. That's it.
it the extra extremes of this and sexual content that raises a title from shonen to seinen.
And more complex plotting and characterization.
To generalize the whole shonen media as being poor and not complex enough is completely is idotic statement
Saying that with titles like Barefoot Gen, Death Note, Devilman, GetBackers or Neon Genesis Evangelion as not having complex plotting and characterization is absolutely stupid.
To refuse even try to read a manga because it from shonen jump reeks of the childish attitude as it not seinen it must completely devoid of depth.
I read both Berserk & Claymore they have some similarity with the medievel setting and both on journey of revenge. They both fill a similar void if you like one you certaintly find something to enjoy in the other.
If you don't like shonen fighting titles so much why do you like berserk, which is frankly one most similar senien to shonen fighting style:
A lead character on journey to get stronger, to defeat an enemy currently out of his league while defeating bunch of lesser enemy which make him stronger. Taging along with him is other characters which incase offer comical relief, emotion value or help fighting a similar cause support him later battles. That incredibly to similar plot line for most shonen mangas.
The line between a shonen title and seinen is incredibly thin, a title is classed as shonen/seien only by the style of manga anthology it published in, to generalise one or other with out reading shows ignorance.
fabricatedlunatic said:
Dave said:
To slag of title because it from shonen jump without experience it frankly makes you look like idiot.
Good God. What is it with anime fans and reading comprehension?
You are dismissing title without putting the effort to read it and where it published, that is idiocy.
Rui: On subject of rudeness he has dismissed whole genre and is refusing reading a single shonen title as it from shonen magazine and is swearing like 5 year old who just learned them at playground.
I enjoy varity of manga/animes types and you don't see me demising titles i have not read/watched. I really enjoyed sailor moon anime uncut for example but i didn't enjoy watching kimba white lion as an example but it least i put the effort into watching the title to get fair view on it.