cudwieser
Student Council President
Couldn't find a better place for this (if any of the mods can please let me know). I put it here for the fact that Alita: Battle Angel seems based of the anime
Trailer #1
The anime wasn't bad. In truth it is very watchable, but having read the manga it is sorely lacking in depth and a lot of context. While I cannot judge the depth and finesse of the story in the live action film. I can say one thing, the art direction (especially with Gally) in the trailer looks bad. I'm not expecting a pixel for pixel clone here and more for that reason I would have apprecated Alita with more human eyes and expression. Cyborg or not she stands out like a sore thumb in that trailer. Too cutesy and fake. If the trailer actually gave us a human charater (with more human features) and played to the dark, survivalist, anti-hero nature of the manga instead of the cutesy, love dovey tagline and anime I'd be very impressed.
As it is my skepticism is running very high now and I ask what your opinions of the trailer are going by what you know of the manga and anime film.
Trailer #1
The anime wasn't bad. In truth it is very watchable, but having read the manga it is sorely lacking in depth and a lot of context. While I cannot judge the depth and finesse of the story in the live action film. I can say one thing, the art direction (especially with Gally) in the trailer looks bad. I'm not expecting a pixel for pixel clone here and more for that reason I would have apprecated Alita with more human eyes and expression. Cyborg or not she stands out like a sore thumb in that trailer. Too cutesy and fake. If the trailer actually gave us a human charater (with more human features) and played to the dark, survivalist, anti-hero nature of the manga instead of the cutesy, love dovey tagline and anime I'd be very impressed.
As it is my skepticism is running very high now and I ask what your opinions of the trailer are going by what you know of the manga and anime film.