RUN FORREST, RUN!
The first word that comes to mind when thinking of this finale is "clumsy". I don't know if it's just me but the pacing was all over the place. It could be a source material issue. I know that episode 21 finished where Volume 7 ended, and Volume 8 only came out two weeks ago. They may very well have had to have rushed the last three episodes to coincide with that volume. Toradora was in a similar situation, but that handled it in a much smoother and more organic way. That might have been the staff having an influence. Not that Golden Time's staff were slouches (the writer handled the scripts for the likes of Full Metal Panic and the director did Higurashi and some later series of Nodame Cantabile), but Toradora had the incredible Tatsuyuki Nagai and Mari Okada dream team. I ultimately found the ending somewhat unsatisfactory due to the way it was presented, and with the resolution.
My main issue with Golden Time's actual story was never resolved. I never bought the relationship between Banri and Koko for one second. I can totally understand Banri falling for Koko. She does have an incredibly magnetic presence. I never felt that Koko genuinely loved Banri back, but rather just wanted love full stop. In this final episode, during her long speech on the bridge, her line "I need you" stuck out to me. I may be overthinking this a bit, but her choosing the word "need" speaks volumes about their relationship. For a brief period, I thought the series was going to explore the theme of relationships that weren't healthy, and show the consequences of that. At university I witnessed a couple of my friends go through similar unhealthy relationships, I think it could have been a bold direction and made for a potentially more interesting series. Once again going back to Toradora, one of its real strengths is that I could see any of the main relationships plausibly working, which added to the drama.
I'm still undecided on the entire Ghost Banri plot angle. While there were times it legitimately added to the drama (the holiday and the car accident for example), there were also times were it felt too forced and unnatural. This episode in particular with the entire scene on the bridge with the multiple Banris didn't work for me at all. What should have been a powerful moment with Linda turned into a "Eh, what happened?" reaction. That added to my feeling of dissatisfaction.
Still, despite my issues, there was still a hell of a lot to like in Golden Time. I really did grow fond of the core cast. Linda-senpai stood out in particular. She was in a tough situation throughout and I really sympathised with her story. 2D-Kun, Mitsuo and Oka-chan were very likeable characters too. Koko may have many many flaws that made her tough to like at times, but she was always an incredibly compelling character to watch. While I didn't particularly care for Ghost Banri or pre-memory loss Banri in general, post-loss Banri was generally quite interesting too. I did like his attitude and his sense of humour a lot. The way the characters bounced off each other was really fun to watch.
The opening episodes in particular really captured the great feeling of going to university. When Golden Time was funny, it was very very funny. From the moment the Latin Music club showed up all the way up to EXORCIST, there was always something to make me laugh. For all the occasional lapses in execution, in general the episodes went at a hell of a clip and I was never once bored. I always came back every week too so it was definitely doing something right.