which anime would you want to of continued from the manga

Joshawott said:
Reading the manga, the anime adaptation was pretty faithful, only the odd, slight things with no significance whatsoever were left out or changed. .
Pacing was really awful, cut out a fair bit of content and **** all over the bit I was anticipating most. The most grimdark moment of FMA inside of Gluttony's stomach. But eh, FMA never got as good or dark as that again and started getting stale and more Shounen-ish.
 
To be honest, much as originally I THOUGHT I'd want a continuation of Claymore, I'm not sure I would anymore. Whilst the author has some ideas, his pacing is absolutely terrible, and I get the feeling he's either really dragging his pacing and plot out, or he's not entirely sure where to go with it.

Claymore is a fun series, but its fights are notoriously dragged out, especially as it's a monthly, not a weekly series, and I think a second season could have got painful.

It doesn't help that Claire, like it or not is the main protagonist, and we've not even seen her for quite a while in the story, unknown DOA.
 
alexrose1uk said:
To be honest, much as originally I THOUGHT I'd want a continuation of Claymore, I'm not sure I would anymore. Whilst the author has some ideas, his pacing is absolutely terrible, and I get the feeling he's either really dragging his pacing and plot out, or he's not entirely sure where to go with it.

Claymore is a fun series, but its fights are notoriously dragged out, especially as it's a monthly, not a weekly series, and I think a second season could have got painful.

It doesn't help that Claire, like it or not is the main protagonist, and we've not even seen her for quite a while in the story, unknown DOA.

i dont like Claire i really dont like her
 
I wan't a sequel to Dance in the Vampire Bund.

Also, I haven't read the manga, but I heard that Rosario to Vampire anime edition did not follow it and a lot of people complained because of this, so a reboot would be nice with the story from the manga (like they did with Fullmetal Alchmist). I just God hope that Tsukune is not a whimp in the manga, like in the anime.
 
Rui said:
I would personally like to see more Moribito, with the stories from the later books given TV series of the same quality as the first one. 12 Kingdoms would be an automatic nomination too if it wasn't for the fact that I believe the novel series is still unfinished and I'd rage even more if it got resumed then stopped again.
It may well be incomplete, but at some stage I think you have to label it "finished" unless she shows some desire to write more than a 100 pages every few years. :s

As for Moribito, have you watched Kemono no Souja Erin? Although I agree it would be cool to get more of the Moribito series adapted, too.
 
Tind said:
I wan't a sequel to Dance in the Vampire Bund.

Also, I haven't read the manga, but I heard that Rosario to Vampire anime edition did not follow it and a lot of people complained because of this, so a reboot would be nice with the story from the manga (like they did with Fullmetal Alchmist). I just God hope that Tsukune is not a whimp in the manga, like in the anime.

The first season of the anime did more or less follow the first chapters of the manga until the finale with the a few exceptions and with some arcs shuffled to introduce Mizore quicker.
The second season was 90% non canon though.
I suggest you checkout the manga, it starts off similar to the show but rapidly gets stronger and has an overall much lower fanservice use.

By the time you hit manga season 2 its an extremely different beast. Tsukune also gets massive development. He starts off wimpy at the very beginning but develops into anything but, he becomes less wimpy quite quickly too although it's taken some 80 odd chapters to get where we are now.
 
But I need to know what happens to Taiki ;_;

ilmaestro said:
As for Moribito, have you watched Kemono no Souja Erin? Although I agree it would be cool to get more of the Moribito series adapted, too.

I haven't, though I think it was the first thing I ever added to my CR 'to watch' list and it still stares balefully back at me, waiting for that moment when I'm stranded somewhere without my DVDs nearby and in need of something good to watch.

R
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top