Er, that's not why I didn't like FFVIII's fight system. I finished the game with no problems at all.
The reason I am lukewarm about it is similar to the way I feel about FFIII - it penalises you if you want to be flexible about how you play it. I am a very big magic user in FF games. The draw system was innately flawed if you play the way I prefer to and actually use your magic - it rewarded you more to spend hours drawing tons of magic then hoard it instead of using it. If you cast any serious amount of magic your stats dropped or you had to spend another 15 minutes getting it back again. That sort of thing does my OCD no good at all! Interesting, but a little disappointing.
FFIII is exactly the same - it feels more balanced for melee classes and abilities (limit breaks in particular featured quite heavily in VIII or whatever they called them in English in that game - I played it in JP). I struggled in FFIII until I gave up and started playing the way I was clearly "supposed to" be playing it with my party configuration and it was suddenly very easy. Still a fun game, but not as fun as one where I feel more able to experiment.
The GFs were brilliant in VIII. I did feel they rather replaced the utility of other magic though, even more so than in other summon-heavy games in the series.
I also really, really hated Squall. I get what they were trying to do with him and I know it's not always realistic to like every character but I genuinely felt gratification each time he bought it and left him lying there dead far longer than I needed to before resurrecting him. Irvine was fun though.
VIII had some fantastically innovative concepts (particularly the playing around with the standard storytelling format that they tried) but I felt it needed more polish to give it a chance of being one of my favourites (which are, as mentioned before, VI and IX). It wasn't rounded enough to make it for me but I don't regret playing it at all. Twice. Thanks to my memory card
Anyway sorry for the ramble, just couldn't let that deliberately argumentative attend to undermine everyone who dares have a different preference to you stand without an attempt at a rebuttal!
R