Wildcard said:
Doberman Pharaoh said:
It's all about opinions.
End of topic.
I'll second that.
Thirded, the trick is to find a like minded reviewer (hence why always look at the Raxpehon review first :roll: ).
Aaron said:
What's the difference between 78% and 79%?
This is a bugbear of mine, but more from work. For example on a 1-5 scale what does 3 mean? As far as I'm concerned it means
Average, As expected, Normal. According to my boss getting this on a review form means you have to spend the next 1/2 hr explaining why you fouled up so badly, Again finding a review system you understand and agree with helps, as some site give more than one rating, for example
My Anime List give 5 scores for aspects of the show and an overall score, while
ANN give a seperate grade for the sub and dub.
The last question that no one has asked (or if it was i missed, sorry) is how big a chunk of the anime do you review.
By episode,
by dvd, or
by the whole series. Episode reviews give lots of detail, but may miss out the larger picture, DVD reviews tell you what you get for your money, but the episodes may not be split at logical cut off points for a longer series. Full series reviews are good, but often give away twists or the ending.