Review of Golgo 13: Queen Bee

Professor Irony

CYBER FUNKER
Moderator
Hmm. I'd definitely agree that the action scenes aren't as memorable as they were in The Professional and the sheer amount of sex drives the film close to self-parody, but I think the lack of development for Golgo as a character is purely a reflection of the source material.

I can understand that it probably seems baffling for the title character to be a bit player in his own film, but that is basically how the series has progressed over the years. It wasn't the case in earlier stories, but as the manga went on, Duke became a peripheral figure. The man himself was less important than the myth surrounding him and he himself becomes this black hole of a character who seems to exist only to carry out the destructive wishes of others.

It doesn't change the development of the characters around him, which could certainly be better (although I did find Sonia more sympathetic than I think you did), but basically that's the kicker; Duke isn't developed because he's not supposed to be.

Comparing Queen Bee to The Professional, I'd have said this was the more accessible film to those unfamiliar with the franchise, but then again, maybe not...
 
Clicking on the review from the front page I get...

"You have an error in your SQL syntax; check the manual that corresponds to your MySQL server version for the right syntax to use near 'AND anime_genre.genre_id = genre.genre_id ORDER BY RAND() LIMIT 1' at line 4"
 
Will fix in a sec, not sure how this has happened but there may be some minor turbulence :)

R
 
<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/2011-08-151.jpg">

<b>Review of Golgo 13: Queen Bee by HdE</b>

Appearing in Japan in Shogakukan's Big Comic since 1969, it's fair to say that Golgo 13 is something of a big deal over there. Being one of the prime candidates for the title of 'longest running manga ever', it may come as something of a surprise to learn that the feature discussed here is only the second anime adaptation of the mysterious hitman's adventures. What's more surprising is that, having been produced in 1998, it took almost thirty years for this popular property to get to that milestone.

The plot of this short film concerns Duke Togo - the prolific assassin-for-hire otherwise known as Golgo 13 - being hired to bump off the revolutionary figure known as 'Queen Bee'. Queen Bee, AKA Sonya, is the leader of a dissident South American guerrilla group hell bent on murdering a presidential candidate. She also happens to be - wouldn't you know it - a beautiful redhead prone to shedding her clothes at a moment's notice. As the story progresses, a link between Sonya and the presidential candidate, James Hardy, emerges, which throws things into a different light. And all the while, Golgo 13 is watching...

This 60 minute feature constitutes a standalone story, rather than a direct sequel to the earlier 'Golgo 13: The Professional', and requires no knowledge of that film to pick up and start watching. However, it bears all the hallmarks of that earlier movie. We've got a cocktail of sex, violence, and shady characters to sample, but this time with some advanced production values, relatively speaking.

Animation is of a cleaner standard than it was in 'The Professional' - which stands to reason given the 15 year gap between the two productions. However, while the cel animation is a lot cleaner, it's not necessarily all that appealing. Murky colour palettes and some ill-advised action effects make the film look like a confusing mess at times. In fact, it's quite possible that you'll prefer the look of the 1983 film. For my money at least, that movie may not have the more advanced visual stylings of this one, but it's animated with a better sense of motion and style. Your mileage may vary.<br>
Queen Bee also features quite heavy use of painted stills throughout - a traditional anime storytelling device which, depending on your opinion, either looks stylish or cheap. It doesn't look out of place here, at least, and overall, while it may not be the most pleasing aesthetic, it builds a certain ambience. That's an ethic which carries over to the soundtrack, which is certainly nothing special, but does a good job of evoking a certain 1980s spy movie feel. It feels a bit dated, but fits like a glove. So the stage is set for an atmospheric adventure, at least.

Unfortunately, Queen Bee is hamstrung by a number of quite serious problems. The plot, while it sounds solid enough on paper, is actually pretty slender. The tension-free, by-the-numbers story execution makes it feel pretty perfunctory, as if it's a half-hearted framework for the writers to tack a bit of sex and violence onto. The result is what feels like an animated Steven Segal movie with extra nookie. And less one-liners.

The plot development and the fashion in which the story advances are pretty woeful. For example, Sonya identifies Duke Togo at a bar immediately, without any indication as to HOW she knows who he is. We're then subjected to the sight of their first sexual liaison with nary a hint of chemistry or build up between the two, save a few lines of unconvincing dialogue. This kind of illogical progression makes the 'adult' content of the movie feel totally gratuitous and forced in.

There's not a single sympathetic character in the entire story, either. Sonya - the eponymous Queen Bee herself - is fleshed out with a back story, but has so little character beyond 'I'm a guerrilla freedom fighter, and I have sex with lots of men' that she doesn't leave much of a mark. President James Hardy, who has the potential early on to develop into a credible, conflicted character, is derailed by a character arc that reaches a preposterous resolution. He's also not helped by an embarrassingly bad turn by Dwight Schultz in the dub, proving aptly why TV actors don't necessarily make for good voice actors.

But, unforgivably, it's Duke Togo/Golgo 13 himself who is just too hard to take. He's a personality-free, expressionless killer, about as one-dimensional as you can get. It could be argued that this is at least in keeping with previous depictions for the character, but really, that's not much of a recommendation. He's always been one of the most unappealing, underdeveloped non-characters in anime for my liking, and there's nothing here to make me question that opinion. He's simply not a strong enough lead to carry this feature, and I was left after 60 minutes wondering why on Earth Golgo 13 has enjoyed such popularity for so long.

At the end of the day, fans of Golgo 13 may welcome this additional animated escapade. But truthfully it's a clumsy, corny, forgettable story with astonishingly poor story development. Loaded with cliches and devoid of excitement, it's hard to see what this could offer to anyone unfamiliar with the property.

Definitely one to pass up.<br>
<b>Final score: 4 out of 10</b>
 
Sparrowsabre7 said:
Hey, you said to ignore this so I did the exact opposite and noticed it, I hope that's ok.

You whippersnapper! :)

Ok apologies for the temporal paradox but I didn't want to destroy everyone's comments. Please pretend the posts above HdE's review come after it.

R
 
ConanThe3rd said:
The 'heck's Renton got to do with Golgo?

I take it there were some glitchy shenanigans going on with this review? I've been away for a convention, so apologies for returning late to the party.

There were some bizarre thing happening with the screenshots on this one. I basically uploaded them at the same time as the Guyver and Eureka 7 reviews I recently typed up for the site.

None of which, alas, alters the fact that this one GODAWFUL OVA.
 
To me, I only liked the 1983 Golgo 13 The Professional anime movie because I really like the character designs and animation in that movie. Also the soundtrack is much much better. The story is alot more straightforward to understand with loads of pretty cool action scenes and interesting enemies.

The English dubbed version of the movie by Streamline Pictures is good as well.
 
Professor Irony said:
Hmm. I'd definitely agree that the action scenes aren't as memorable as they were in The Professional and the sheer amount of sex drives the film close to self-parody

To be honest I always felt The Professional was bordering on self parody in the first place. I mean the sex, the ridiculous villains, the 3D, Golgo himself, oh and that scene... a somewhat disturbing parody then.

I think when it was originally released it was probably more in line with the movies coming out at the time, but if seen now its hard to treat it seriously. In fact I think thats part of the problem, Golgo was such a product of his time that he just doesn't have a place or reason to exist in year 2011, apart from possibly being some kind of iconic retro curiosity.
 
Eh, maybe so. The tv series was a little more down to earth, but I think the Golgo manga always was pretty ridiculous, albeit in a terribly serious way. I still maintain that the best Golgo stories are those that either require him to do something completely bizarre (need to take out a KGB psychic? Learn meditation!) or place him in real-life events, like the punchline to a Chuck Norris-style joke (who fixed the 2000 US elections? Duke Togo.), so I suppose that's the charm really.

As for The Professional, the storyline is definitely over-the-top pulp, but I think it's technically a very interesting film. They aren't all a success, but Dezaki really pulls out all the stops to try about every stylistic flourish he can think of. Weird angles, stop motion, cgi, postcard memories, split screening - it's all there.

As you say though, it's a pretty disturbing watch at times, so I wouldn't consider it a parody particularly. The main thing holding it back for me is just how downright depressing the film is by the time the credits role around, but yeah, I think that probably is down to the style of the time. I see it fitting in rather well with those sort of paranoid, downbeat '70s American conspiracy thrillers like Three Days of the Condor and The Parallax View.
 
^
yeah I've never read the manga nor did I even know there was a TV series so I cant comment on those.

I do agree with you though that from a style/direction point on view the professional is very interesting and unique in ways. And I guess in terms of story it does have sort of bizzare yet cheesy spy thriller sort of appeal, but The Professional just felt all over the place in terms of tone for me. Its got this whole quirky cheesey and humorous 80's spy vibe to it, but is filled with so many extremely explicit occasionally disturbing scenes that I just find the whole thing a jarring experience. Its a film that surely should never take itself seriously yet it does. But again I think it just comes down to the fact that its just too 80's even for me.

In the end I found the whole thing a rather depressing experience much like you. Although to be honest I can't remember if its because it was meant to be or if I felt like I had being exposed to possibly the most misogynistic, gratuitously violent and meaningless film I had ever seen, and to make matters worse it was dressed in the clothes of cheap 80's animation.
 
Point of interest:

I'd deliberately steered clear of referencing the earlier 1983 anime. It's kind of important to me to judge the two movies on their own individual merits (or lack of them).

Now, I'm not going to claim that 'The Professional' is a great movie. Because it's not. But I DO think it has a lot more to admire than Queen Bee on a few levels. Specifically, I think it's a better looking film. True, the animation style may appear obviously dated, but I think there's much more to appreciate there.
 
^
No doubt. Something like Golgo should never have been dug up for the year 2011 and any attempts to do so will almost certainly pale in comparison to the 80's anime. The only way it wouldn't would be if they made significant changes to the franchise, but then you might as well just create something completely new.
 
To be fair, Queen Bee is more than ten years old at this point. If you're curious about how Golgo fares in a modern context, it might be better to look at the TV series (which was 08 ), but the streams are region-locked and I wouldn't recommend lashing out on the R1 dvds for something you're not all that keen on.

HdE said:
Point of interest:

I'd deliberately steered clear of referencing the earlier 1983 anime. It's kind of important to me to judge the two movies on their own individual merits (or lack of them).

I can respect that, but when they have the same director, producer and character designer, I think the comparisons are always going to be inevitable.
 
Professor Irony said:
HdE said:
Point of interest:

I'd deliberately steered clear of referencing the earlier 1983 anime. It's kind of important to me to judge the two movies on their own individual merits (or lack of them).

I can respect that, but when they have the same director, producer and character designer, I think the comparisons are always going to be inevitable.

Indeed. But then, I wasn't here to review 'The Professional', so...

In truth, what kinda galls me about Queen Bee is that there's so much potential to up the game over the last movie. With some 15 years between the two, I'd have hoped there'd be some attempt made to turn out a product that was a little more sophisticated. Instead, this feels like a step backwards.

I've not at present seen the TV series. Can't say as I'm particularly keen to, either. But I do hear that it's a more solid offering.
 
HdE said:
In truth, what kinda galls me about Queen Bee is that there's so much potential to up the game over the last movie. With some 15 years between the two, I'd have hoped there'd be some attempt made to turn out a product that was a little more sophisticated. Instead, this feels like a step backwards.

That's fair. Dezaki's technical wizardry is both less in evidence and less successful than before (that shakey cam thing was a particularly bad move). I do wonder if the inevitable drop in budget from feature film to OAV might have anything to do with it, but I couldn't really say.

The commentary track on the disc isn't particularly illuminating either; about the only significant thing Dezaki and Yamamoto mention is the excising of a homoerotic subplot that probably wouldn't have added much to the film.

vashdaman said:
So what's the series like, any different?

The series is a straight-up adaptation of the manga, cherry-picking 50 individual stories from its lengthy run. I've seen about 15 episodes or so and I'd say it's been softened a little to bring it more in line with modern tastes. Misanthropy and mysogny are still kicking around, but they aren't screaming in your face either. The art is quite nice and the animation is generally okay, but there are some shoddy episodes that drag things down.

They do touch on some interesting stories throughout the show, but as with Lupin, I think the self-contained half-hour format works against it - good episodes are too short, bad ones drag on. Sadly, they've also avoided any stories involving real people, so you won't be seeing Nelson Mandela, Pope John-Paul II or Bill Clinton. :(
 
Back
Top