Review of Death Note #1

Sarah

Staff
AUKN Staff
<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/2008-07-09Death Note 1.jpg">

<b>Review of Death Note #1 by Sarah</b>

"Humans are so much fun!&rdquo; gleefully observes Ryuk, the shinigami, or God of Death, who has oh-so-carelessly dropped his Death Note, the notebook in which he inscribes the names of those who are about to die.<br>
Is it chance that he drops it just where Light Yagami, top honours student at his high school, sees it fall &ndash; and just can&rsquo;t resist picking it up? For inside Ryuk has helpfully inscribed the rules of the Death Note.<br>
Light has everything going for him: the highest test scores in Japan, good looks, and a supportive family, including a father who&rsquo;s high up in the police. But, given all these attributes, Light is very aware of the high levels of crime in the world. And maybe he&rsquo;s been a little bored, unconsciously searching for an intellectual challenge. For him the Death Note symbolizes a way to put all the world&rsquo;s ills to rights. After testing it carefully on a local punk he witnesses attacking a young girl in the street, he decides to put his plan into action. He&rsquo;s going to get rid of all the criminals. He&rsquo;s going to become the god of a new and better world. He will become the wielder of &lsquo;Righteous Justice&rsquo;.<br>
When Ryuk leaves the desolate shinigami world to visit the new owner of his Death Note, Light recovers from the shock of meeting the hideous-looking spectre remarkably quickly. Only the holder of the Death Note can see its original owner, Ryuk tells him, as he accompanies him everywhere he goes. And so begins a bizarre and unlikely partnership, Ryuk carelessly (or so it seems) revealing little by little the pitfalls for a human who uses the Death Note. Light, obsessed with his righteous crusade, keeps Ryuk happy with apples. Apples are a recurrent and potent symbol in &lsquo;Death Note&rsquo;, scarlet and glossy-skinned, or chewed to the core.<br>
All these inexplicable deaths in the criminal community have been flashed across the media world-wide. Internet sites dedicated to &lsquo;Kira&rsquo; (killer) have sprung up. Inspector Yagami, Light&rsquo;s father, is put in charge of the &lsquo;Kira&rsquo; case. As the murders continue, an enigmatic genius, known only as &lsquo;L&rsquo; is brought in to help the Japanese police. And thus begins the deadly duel of intellects as L and Kira try to outwit one another. If either one makes the tiniest mistake, it will mean death.&nbsp; Yet Light is confident enough to taunt L with the question, &lsquo;L, do you know Gods of Death love apples?&rsquo;<br>
With a generous eight episodes in this first release, we see Light make may what be a fatal error. In going after the FBI agents who have secretly arrived in Japan to investigate the murders, he meets one, Raye Pember, who has been shadowing his family. In ingeniously trying to entice him to reveal the identities of his colleagues (Light needs a name and a face to kill) Light is unaware that Raye&rsquo;s fianc&eacute;e, Naomi Misora, is an ex-member of the FBI&hellip;and once worked on a case with L. Has Light been over-confident - and lost the battle of wits?<br>
Reviewing the TV series of &lsquo;Death Note&rsquo; at this stage of the game when the manga has been worldwide phenomenon, not to mention the live-action movies etc., my main task is answering the question, &lsquo;Does it live up to all the hype?&rsquo; And yes, it does. The story is so tightly woven that watching each new development becomes nail-bitingly tense. Watching the lethal battle of wits between the two young men, eccentric genius L (&lsquo;Call me Ryuzaki&rsquo;) and cold-hearted model son and student Light is utterly compulsive. Alongside the moments of horror, there are some nicely-judged ironic moments, as the expressions of the faces of the five police investigators in their smart suits when they first meet L face-to-face and see a shambling, wild-haired young man who abstractedly fills his coffee with sugar lumps as he talks.&nbsp;&nbsp;<br>
The creative team have created an atmospheric and faithful rendering of the original manga (story by Tsugumi Ohba, illustrations by Takeshi Obata), sustaining pace and suspense, whilst not sacrificing any of the telling character-building details. Particularly telling are the allusions to Christian religious art in the opening title sequence, based on Obata&rsquo;s striking covers for the manga; the images of the creation of man and the pieta tell us of Light&rsquo;s monstrous delusions of godhead. The music from Yoshihisa Hirano (&lsquo;Ouran High School Host Club&rsquo;) and Hideki Taniuchi (&lsquo;Otogi Zoshi&rsquo;) effectively enhances the growing sense of foreboding, alternating between echoes of Mike Oldfield&rsquo;s &lsquo;Tubular Bells&rsquo;, and pounding rhythms and chanting choirs.&nbsp;<br>
The English dub comes from one of my favourite teams, Ocean Studios, and is excellent. Brian Drummond, as Ryuk, is strikingly good; grotesquely funny at times, and chillingly knowing at others. Brad Swaile as Light is also extremely convincing, deftly conveying the young man&rsquo;s two faces: the one he shows to the outside world, and the increasingly deranged persona he reveals when alone with Ryuk.<br>
I welcome the fact that eight episodes are contained in the first volume (on two discs). This recent practice of issuing eight or more episodes at a time (as with &lsquo;Bleach&rsquo; and &lsquo;Naruto&rsquo;) makes good economic sense as well as giving the viewer a much better idea of a series &ndash; and I hope that more companies will adopt this practice. There are good extras as well, including&nbsp;'Behind the Scenes'&nbsp;with Brad Swaile (Light) and Alessandro&nbsp;Juliani&nbsp; (L) and interviews with the Japanese Animation Director and Character Designer.<br>
<strong>In Summary</strong><br>
&lsquo;Death Note&rsquo; &ndash; a cautionary tale for our times? Tense, tautly plotted, and claustrophobic, the TV series captures all the best qualities of the original manga and brings them very effectively to animated life. Not comfortable watching, but challenging and utterly involving. And these are&nbsp;only the first episodes&hellip;<br>
<b>Final score: 9 out of 10</b>

<b>Additional screencaps</b>

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2008-07-09Death Note 1 a.jpg">

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2008-07-09Death Note 1 b.jpg">

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2008-07-09Death Note 1 c.jpg">
 
An excellent review.

After watching the series fansubbed a while ago I was pleasantly surprised by how good the English dub turned out, and including eight episodes each on the first two volumes is excellent value (though I'm guessing that volume three will have six, and the remaining releases five).

I can't help but be disappointed however that Manga haven't seized the opportunity this show offers. Death Note has become huge in the states and with some proper marketing the series could perhaps have become a breakthrough show for pushing Anime into the mainstream in the UK.

But alas, it's not to be.
 
LeeDless said:
I can't help but be disappointed however that Manga haven't seized the opportunity this show offers. Death Note has become huge in the states and with some proper marketing the series could perhaps have become a breakthrough show for pushing Anime into the mainstream in the UK.

But alas, it's not to be.
But for that, I believe they might need to also fight the misconcept of "cartoons are for kids". And that is just a little more complicated :(
 
LeeDless said:
I can't help but be disappointed however that Manga haven't seized the opportunity this show offers. Death Note has become huge in the states and with some proper marketing the series could perhaps have become a breakthrough show for pushing Anime into the mainstream in the UK.
It certainly could have been. It's consistently topping the Anime charts at the major online ratailers. Coupled with the fact that the UK release is (shock! horror!) actually *better* value for money than the US one!

Now certainly isn't the time for a company like Manga to be complacent. They licence almost all of the popular shows, and their boxsets (GITS, Naruto, Bleach) sell for very reasonable prices. They must be raking it in. One well placed marketing campaign by them (and Death Note really would have been the perfect show for this) could really make the UK Anime scene explode.

I think Death Note would be great for actively fighting the "Cartoons Are For Kids" preconception too. It would all depend on how it was marketed, of course.
 
then again, I wonder which channel would air them... sci-fi channel comes to mind, but that's all. It's a shame AC is now defunct.
 
chaos said:
then again, I wonder which channel would air them... sci-fi channel comes to mind, but that's all. It's a shame AC is now defunct.
I wasn't really thinking of a TV airing, but just a big marketing campaign to make people buy the dvds. It is the perfect show to grab attention and intrigue people with TV and print adverts.
 
mm, yeah, maybe that would work, but does manga have the mkt people for such a campaign? not to mention the money as well....
 
I do wish the OP would put the images in spoiler-tags, thumbnails or as URL's, I have to keep scrolling to the right to read the posts.
 
LeeDless said:
I do wish the OP would put the images in spoiler-tags, thumbnails or as URL's, I have to keep scrolling to the right to read the posts.
Time for a new monitor. :wink:
 
control minus? I believe this is the hotkey to decrease font size. You can select IE / firefox not to load images automatically.
 
chaos said:
control minus? I believe this is the hotkey to decrease font size. You can select IE / firefox not to load images automatically.
It doesn't help with images though. The text would still flow off to the right if you reduced the text-size - and it would be harder to read as well.
 
Some what on topic but can someone explain to me why oh who mvm decided to realease FLCL volume one on the same day as this?????!!

FLCL 2 episodes £15
Deathnote episodes £15

Not only that but the fact deathnote is a title that a lot of people want. Ill try and do some analogys with the following.

Would anyone realease there film on the same day as the dark knight? No cuz your film would get buried under that realease.

Did anyone in the music industery realease there song on the same day as the spice girls WHEN they were trying to get to number one in the charts and sell more copys?? No because again it would get lost under the spice girls single.


You dont have to be a market expert to know that realeasing your product ON THE SAME DAY as a popular product at better value for money isnt clever....If mvm decided to realease FLCL a month later or earlier it would have sold a few more copys................I swear some of these distros and the anime industery can be stupid at times.
 
Kireek said:
Would anyone realease there film on the same day as the dark knight? No cuz your film would get buried under that realease.
Thats completely different though. Most people i know wouldnt go and see two films in one day yet, they would easily buy two dvds if they wanted them. FLCL, though not on the same level as Death Note, is popular. People will still pay for it regardless of when it comes out.
The amount of sale it would've lost because people were buying Death Note probably isnt even noticable.
 
Kireek said:
Some what on topic but can someone explain to me why oh who mvm decided to realease FLCL volume one on the same day as this?????!!

FLCL 2 episodes £15
Deathnote episodes £15

I already replied to you when you posted this rant in another thread.

FLCL is a direct to video, quirky artsy title aimed at older fans. Death Note is unusually good, fairly long Shounen Jump suspense show with an interesting hook aimed squarely at the mass market (ok, mass *anime* market in the UK, a little different). A lot of anime watchers will not "get" FLCL.

If they released every episode of FLCL on one disc, it would still not have as many episodes as one pack of Death Note. If they halved the price too, they'd make no money on their release at all. They can't win, so they're instead taking the highly reasonable business plan of trying to release it in a way that balances value and profitability so they can afford to release more crazy Gainax stuff.

We still get twice as many episodes per disc as the Japanese did for almost half the price (remember, it was an OAV so it wasn't televised when it came out; they had to buy/rent like we do) and double the language options. I really see little room to complain.

As for choice of months - well it's hard to avoid Death Note, Naruto or Bleach entirely as is at the rate the Shounen Jump series are churned out. And any TV series disc will have more episodes available than FLCL got in its entire run. They're not hoping to outsell the major shounen fare. They simply won't be able to. It's aimed at a different type of fan.

I'd buy FLCL over Death Note if I didn't already have the R2Js (preordered on release as imports and I don't feel ripped off even now it's cheaper; love it).

R
 
Late last year I bought Nurse Witch Komugi from HMV.
It was a six episode OVA which set me back a very reasonable £14.99 for the one and only volume (on release, full RRP).

Fooly Cooly is a six epsode OVA, which is priced at £15.99 each for three volumes, in total £47.97. Interesting.

I understand that the license for the latter show will undoubtedly cost more, nonetheless at that price it in no way, shape or form represents value for money.
It's a great show, but many people (myself included) will feel that kind of money is frankly taking the piss, and you have to wonder if the extra revenue generated from the three volume release is offset by all the people refusing to buy the series now on principle.

Besides, shelf space is now at a premium in my living room, and using up three DVD cases to store only six episodes is just silly. I could squeeze a full thin-pack boxset in there.
 
It's all about how much it's worth to you. If you just want to count up entertainment minutes to the pound, FLCL is a terrible release (and stuff like Yuu Gi Ou is probably brilliant). If you adore quirky shows, a thousand episodes of Naruto isn't worth as much as 5 minutes of FLCL. This time they were banking on the latter group, I guess. It's going to be very hard for them to turn a profit on an expensive (probably) show like FLCL in a budget pack. Gainax is notoriously not cheap and this was a very hyped, beautifully digitally animated effort that they wouldn't be giving away even now.

Assuming they have to sell six episodes at £45 total (ish) to be profitable with the current market size, I suppose they were caught in a corner. Releasing it in one box would be neater, but the lump price would scare people off and there'd be no turning back if they don't like it. Releasing six single volumes would probably annoy everyone even more and cost more due to increased distribution charges. They picked three volumes as a happy medium but upset both crowds a little as a result.

Two packs at £20 each would probably have hit the sweet spot a little better after online discounts. Maybe there was more behind their decision though, like encoding quality concerns or a marketing problem. I don't know...

It's bound to come out cheaper later on when it's earned its keep (or end up in sales) which is how I pick up titles I'm less excited about.

I agree about shelf space issues (a Beez style slim release would have been nicer even if the total price was the same) but early adoption and shelf space concerns rarely see eye to eye. My R2J FLCL was in six individual DVD cases so from that perspective they did manage to improve it even for the initial [UK] release.

I wouldn't like to see it on a single disc though, just a double pack at best. It is too visually busy for me to believe it wouldn't look terrible on a single, dual-language DVD.

R
 
Rui said:
FLCL is a direct to video, quirky artsy title aimed at older fans. Death Note is unusually good, fairly long Shounen Jump suspense show with an interesting hook aimed squarely at the mass market (ok, mass *anime* market in the UK, a little different). A lot of anime watchers will not "get" FLCL.

If they released every episode of FLCL on one disc, it would still not have as many episodes as one pack of Death Note. If they halved the price too, they'd make no money on their release at all. They can't win, so they're instead taking the highly reasonable business plan of trying to release it in a way that balances value and profitability so they can afford to release more crazy Gainax stuff.

We still get twice as many episodes per disc as the Japanese did for almost half the price (remember, it was an OAV so it wasn't televised when it came out; they had to buy/rent like we do) and double the language options. I really see little room to complain.

As for choice of months - well it's hard to avoid Death Note, Naruto or Bleach entirely as is at the rate the Shounen Jump series are churned out. And any TV series disc will have more episodes available than FLCL got in its entire run. They're not hoping to outsell the major shounen fare. They simply won't be able to. It's aimed at a different type of fan.

I'd buy FLCL over Death Note if I didn't already have the R2Js (preordered on release as imports and I don't feel ripped off even now it's cheaper; love it).

R

Thing is though; its still a horrible price thats practically robbery. I wouldnt buy FLCL, simply because im not eager enough to throw money down the drain.

If they know it wont sell well in the UK, dont release it here, just let us import it *Shrug*. But oh we must support UK Anime Industry, thats fine but, they'll just have to settle for less money. Frankly, I find it a rip off.
 
Back
Top