Review of Bamboo Blade #1

Reevothemusefan

Vampire Ninja
<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/2010-10-2315784510x.jpg">

<b>Review of Bamboo Blade #1 by Reevothemusefan</b>

Although I am still a newcomer to the UK anime market, I'm pretty sure that we haven't been graced with an anime based on a sport before; the genre might have been evident in some parts of certain anime but there hasn't been one hugely focused on the subject. It was only a matter of time until something came along; however, it turned out to be based around the traditional Japanese sport of kendo: Bamboo Blade.<br>
This isn't the first time I've encountered the series; I had a read-through of the first volume of the manga (by Masahiro Totsuka) which gave me the gist of what to expect.<br>
Bamboo Blade starts at Muroe High School kendo club where team captain Kirino Chiba is shown practising her sword movements to the unmotivated part-time teacher and Kendo instructor Toraji Ishida (nicknamed Kojiro.) With no new members coming to the club and being in financial difficulty adding to his problems, it&rsquo;s not until Kojiro meets his old kendo coach Kenzaburo Ishibashi - who offers a bet of free sushi for a year if he can beat his female kendo team -&nbsp; that he finds the determination to encourage more girls to join the club.<br>
Bamboo Blade introduces its main characters as the episodes progress: the experienced and kindly Yuji Nakata; the strange, simple-looking Danjuro Eiga who introduces his beautiful yet sadistic minded girlfriend Miyako Miyazaki to the sport (I say this because when she is with Eiga her persona is very kind and supportive but without him she shows her bad attitude); Sayako Kuwahara, who sets various goals for herself that change from time to time; Satori Azuma, who is a strong kendo fighter but struggles with her studies, and last, but not least, Tamaki Kawazoe, the female lead.<br>
At the start Tamaki comes off as an anti-social student but is one of the best at kendo; however she does it all the time at home and finds it a chore, thus showing no interest in joining the club.&nbsp; After being mistaken as some kind of hero to protect the club from evil, she joins up and we come to learn that even though she confident and shows no nerves in kendo, she is human when doing basic tasks for friends. Kojiro is another example; even though he is the adult and leader of the team, he acts like a child when he wants his way, reminding me of Yukari Tanizaki from Azumanga Daioh. This sheds light on how the members of the team befriend and help each other to become better fighters.<br>
As a person who only knows kendo from hours of playing Persona 3, I find the series does very well to explain the traditional gear, the footwork that&rsquo;s involved, and how to score in a match. Comedy is also a factor in Bamboo Blade and its gags feel more random than anything; some parts of the episodes made me chuckle - like the supermarket scene &ndash; but nothing hilarious.
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;
As for the presentation of the series, it shows typical anime emotives, chibi and moe-looking characters for most of the female cast, which is never a bad thing in my book. The voice acting in both English and Japanese is acceptable.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;<br>
My gripe&nbsp;is&nbsp;that after the main practice match in the middle of the episodes the series heads into mediocrity with the plot struggling to find out what it wants to do next. Some character development does help but it felt boring at times. The 3D effects in episode one are unnecessary, but thankfully they are not used again.<br>
Extras are few&nbsp;with the Textless Opening to &ldquo;Bamboo Beat&rdquo; and Textless Closing to &ldquo;Star Rise&rdquo; which are forgettable J-Pop songs.<br>
In Summary<br>
Excellent character development and great kendo fights are enough for me to recommend this to anyone who has an interest in the series; it&rsquo;s not a perfect start, with some shortcomings, but good enough to gain a decent score.<br>
<b>Final score: 8 out of 10</b>

<b>Additional screencaps</b>

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2010-10-23vlcsnap-448635.png">

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2010-10-23vlcsnap-452885.png">

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2010-11-13vlcsnap-447289.png">
 
I received this a number of days prior to its official release, thanks to HMV. The enjoyment I derived out of 1-13 alone made it tempting to buy the manga... until I remembered my recent £140 TBD buying spree... and my £65-70 eBay manga purchasing... and I realized that the manga art is rather poor, compared to the anime's.

BB is very good, very character-focused fun. Kendo is very much secondary to characterization throughout. The first half of the series deals almost completely with introducing and fleshing out the cast, and a great job of doing so was done. The Kendo teacher was made super likable by his supermarket war with an old hag, and Miya-Miya's lovey-dovey/sadistic split-personality make her an easy favourite.

My only disappoint was with the Kendo, really. The animation consisted more of speed-lines than actual animation, and I still don't really get how precise strikes need to be for points to be scored. I was still able to care about the kendo side but I got far more enjoyment out of Tama learning to be more social by working part-time at a shop and the teacher returning home to his parents.

I'm looking forward to the second half. Maybe, for once, I'll actually come to like a two-part Manga series?...
 
Apparently the series is wrapped up with a fairly dramatic anime-onry story to provide some closure. This has the potential to go horribly wrong but I don't want to prejudge anything. Well, I do, but I won't.

Nice review. We have had sports anime before in the UK, with Princess Nine. (I'm fairly sure that was released here.) Also there was Slow Step on VHS back in the mid-1990s.
 
Good review Reevothemusefan. It also nice to see more sports related anime being released.

fabricatedlunatic said:
Apparently the series is wrapped up with a fairly dramatic anime-onry story to provide some closure. This has the potential to go horribly wrong but I don't want to prejudge anything. Well, I do, but I won't.

Nice review. We have had sports anime before in the UK, with Princess Nine. (I'm fairly sure that was released here.) Also there was Slow Step on VHS back in the mid-1990s.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Princess_Nine

Wikipedia says that Princess Nine was released in North America by ADV Films, but no mention is made of a UK release.
 
I think the only sport related anime that we've had have been racing shows like Initial D (1 part), IGPX, Oban Star Racers...

Yeah, fantasy futuristic sports like Angelic Layer...

Every shonen show has some kind of tournament in...

One off episodes like the Baseball ep in Samurai Champloo, the Mah-jong ep in Saiyuki Reload

But actual sports sports...

There was Suzuka, but that only got as far as volume 4.
 
Btw, guys, if you want to get screencaps from DVDs using VLC, do this:
Video > Deinterlace > Blend
..makes the footage look ALOT better ^_^

Also, I might wait for a complete boxset of this show
 
fabricatedlunatic said:
This has the potential to go horribly wrong but I don't want to prejudge anything..

No point over-thinking it - you'll 5-6/10 it, purely because it's actually quite good. Maybe the variation between each school girls' personality might save it, but since I 8'd it...
 
Good to see Aion enjoyed it and for many of the reasons I did. The development of Tama is the best character development I have seen in an anime for quite a while.

To answer the question on scoring a strike in Kendo, I believe three things have to come together to be a valid score. 1. announce the target as you strike hand/arm, body or head. 2. Strike with the correct part of the blade, the cord that holds the end cap on denotes the back of the blade. 3. Strike with force of intent, this can be the most important as a judge can call a strike shallow and not score the point even if everything else is correct. Also just wailing with the shinai won't score you any points, style is required.
 
fabricatedlunatic said:
Hmm, no mention of it at the BBFC either. Weird, because it's advertised on the insert of ADV UK's Gunsmith Cats. IT'S A CONSPIRACY.

its-a-conspiracy.jpg


Thanks for the positive posts guys! Sport anime is a bit underrated in the UK so its very hard to find any releases solely based on it.

Tama and Kojiro's character development is one of the big highlights of the boxset, That certain part-job Tama takes part in for a gift is really entertaining.

Hopefully if this is a successful here we might see more Sport releases like Cross Game and Giant Killing.....I really want a Giant Killing release.
 
Paradox295 said:
Btw, guys, if you want to get screencaps from DVDs using VLC, do this:
Video > Deinterlace > Blend
..makes the footage look ALOT better ^_^

Also, I might wait for a complete boxset of this show
Deinterlace> Disable is the correct for screencaps.
Need to see what the actual video looks like, if it's interlaced best to show that.

It's makes the footage look bad beacuse it is bad, that ghosting and interlace is actualy there, you're reviewing not advertising the disk.
 
Although I am still a newcomer to the UK anime market, I'm pretty sure that we haven't been graced with an anime based on a sport before; the genre might have been evident in some parts of certain anime but there hasn't been one hugely focused on the subject.

Wrong.

Very wrong.

So wrong it hurts. Sports anime are not the most popular, but they are still a huge enough subgenre that you can't dismiss them. Admittedly, you confess to being new to anime, but this is not something that's hard to find out (or at least, don't make such an assertion until you've made an effort to find out). Go onto any anime database site and click on a 'sport' tag and see how much anime comes up that are purely or predominantly about a specific sport and add drama as a side dish. There are even lots that are extremely popular e.g. Eyeshield21 (American football).

If you're interested in discovering the absolute zenith, the cream of the sports genre, you'll want Hajime no Ippo (boxing) and Major (baseball). I cannot emphasise enough how stupendously, rip-roaringly good these shows are.

I've heard good things about Cross Game (baseball), Ookiku Furikabutte (baseball) and Giant Killing (football, and released in time for the 2010 World Cup).

Lesser shows but still worth checking out include One Outs (baseball via Death Note type antics) and Prince of Tennis (tennis), .

As a kid, I also watched a couple old ones targeted at young girls like Attack No. 1 (volleyball) and Hikaru no Densetsu (gymnastics). Sports shows aimed at girls, however, are far rarer these days.

One thing I will admit about Bamboo Blade, which sets it apart from most sports shows, is that it puts far greater emphasis on the personal development of its (female, yay!) characters. Really, this show is weighed 50-50 in terms of sport and drama, while most others are 70-30 in favour of sport.
 
Did you notice the words "UK anime market" (presumably what Reevo meant by "we" in the sentence you emboldened) there? I presume he's referring to the fact that this is one of the first sporting anime series' to see a release in the UK.
 
ayase said:
Did you notice the words "UK anime market" (presumably what Reevo meant by "we" in the sentence you emboldened) there? I presume he's referring to the fact that this is one of the first sporting anime series' to see a release in the UK.

No I didn't. Or, I saw the words, but didn't connect with him meaning Bamboo Blade's uniqueness purely in the UK market. Indeed, it makes more sense that way.

In any case, my recommendations stand. Major has not been licenced (almost certainly never will be) and is thus VERY available, whereas Hajime no Ippo is in R1. Nobody's experience of the sports genre should be purely Bamboo Blade.
 
VivisQueen said:
One thing I will admit about Bamboo Blade, which sets it apart from most sports shows, is that it puts far greater emphasis on the personal development of its (female, yay!) characters. Really, this show is weighed 50-50 in terms of sport and drama, while most others are 70-30 in favour of sport.
Captain Tsubasa and Slam Dunk ommisions. tut tut. Slam Dunk being one of the top selling manga, it's shounen Jump's 4th highest seller (after One Piece, Kochikame and Dragon Ball).
It's a major subgere of shounen manga, along with harem and (fighting) tournament.


Bamboo Blade is also odd in that it's seinen not shounen, like basicaly every other sports manga. It's about their (antihero) teacher, not a team member hero/heroine.

Suffice to say I'm not buying this because it's a sports series (I generaly don't like them) but beacuase it's a modern seinen (character based, no real lead, tons of moe) series, something else we never get in the UK.
 
Captain Tsubasa and Slam Dunk omissions - congratualations on recommending better manga instead, I think you mean (although I don't overly dislike either, especially Captain Tsubasa).

The real things that shouldn't go without mentioning are series like Touch and Ashita no Joe.
 
ReapergI

I didn't mention Slam Dunk or Captain Tsubasa or Ashita no Joe (among others) because I had heard of them but not heard anything sufficient to give me any idea of their entertainment value. That might simply have to do with me having my head in the sand OR the kind of forum I hang around in where I'm probably the only person who watches that much sports anime.

Incidentally, I take that 'tut tut' slap in the face and will prove to you my immense womanliness by watching Slam Dunk in the foreseeable future. Take that!

PS. Here is a really good article by Clarissa of AnimeWorldOrder fame about baseball anime: http://www.otakuusamagazine.com/Anime/N ... _1577.aspx
 
Back
Top