Review of Whisper of the Heart - Blu-Ray edition

darkstorm

Writer Class Servant
AUKN Staff
<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/2012-01-15whisper of the heart.jpg">

<b>Review of Whisper of the Heart - Blu-Ray edition by darkstorm</b>

<p style="margin: 0cm 0cm 10pt" class="MsoNormal"><font size="2"><span lang="EN-GB">I think every anime fan goes through a &lsquo;Studio Ghibli&rsquo; phase at least once. After the major success of Spirited Away across the globe, the studio&nbsp;and its co-founder Hayao Miyazaki were officially put on the radar of Western movie lovers. Not long after, the back catalogue, as well as all future releases of Studio Ghibli, have kindly been made much more widely and commercially available by the likes of The Walt Disney </span><span style="mso-ascii-font-family: Calibri; mso-ascii-theme-font: minor-latin; mso-hansi-font-family: Calibri; mso-hansi-theme-font: minor-latin" lang="EN-GB">company, Optimum and Studio</span><span lang="EN-GB"> Canal &ndash; the latter kindly graces the Blu-ray edition of one of Ghibli&rsquo;s classics, Whisper of the Heart, into UK stores. Being somewhat prequel to my personal favourite Ghibli feature, The Cat Returns, the blu-ray release gave me another chance to view the film I hadn&rsquo;t seen since my first viewing in my teens when I went through my own Ghibli period in my anime fandom. So how does an upgrade in visuals and disc format reflect on the aging on this story? </span></font><br>
<p style="margin: 0cm 0cm 10pt" class="MsoNormal"><span lang="EN-GB"><font size="2">Let&rsquo;s start from the beginning; the film follows a young girl named Suzuku Tsukishima who&rsquo;s in her final year of junior high. She should be spending her free time in the summer studying for her exams to get into High School but instead the imaginative girl has her head up in the clouds, constantly reading fantasy stories from the library. Her dreams turn romantic when she realizes that a mysterious boy by the name of Seiji Amasawa has checked out all the books she&rsquo;s read too. Whilst helping out her friend by re-writing the lyrics to &lsquo;Take Me Home, Country Road&rsquo; for graduation, she bumps into a fellow male student who calls her lyrics &lsquo;corny&rsquo;. Upset and angry but she doesn&rsquo;t let it affect her too much until she randomly decides to follow a cat after getting off a train just to experience an &lsquo;adventure&rsquo;, leading her to bump into the boy again. She eventually discovers that the cheeky boy and &lsquo;Seiji Amasawa&rsquo; are one and the same. After exchanging their dreams whilst studying for exams, love eventually blooms as Suzuku aspires to become a writer and Seiji reveals his wish to study in Italy and become a violin maker. Do their dreams conflict? Or can the pair be together and have their dreams come true as well? </font></span><br>
<p style="margin: 0cm 0cm 10pt" class="MsoNormal"><font size="2"><span lang="EN-GB">Despite being considered a &lsquo;classic&rsquo; of Studio Ghibli&rsquo;s the feature is actually very different compared to other classics such as Kiki&rsquo;s Delivery Service and Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind. The obvious difference is that Whisper of the Heart isn&rsquo;t a fantasy based tale; Suzuku isn&rsquo;t a witch, there's no moving castles and nothing truly &lsquo;magical&rsquo; takes place within the actual story itself. Instead the film is a coming-of-age story; Suzuku goes among her daily school life, helping friends with crushes and deals with her regular family problems, she then falls for a boy at school herself only to find that he plans to leave the country to go after his own dreams. This shakes Suzuku&rsquo;s world and realises she doesn&rsquo;t know what she wants to do with her own life after junior high, she questions who she is and what she does, and it&rsquo;s through her love of writing and Seiji that she grows as a person. The story itself is cute, nothing overly original or amazing, but nicely paced (if a little slow at the beginning) and captures the innocence of falling in love, whilst incorporating elements of growing up and the reality of how chasing after your dreams isn&rsquo;t always so easy, subtly and very well. Since Suzuku is young of age, however, and very much into fairy tales this gives Studio Ghibli an opportunity to weave the &lsquo;feel&rsquo; of fantasy into the story. The clear point where Studio Ghibli goes wild in this territory is within Suzuku&rsquo;s attempts to write an original story about the cat statue she finds in an antique shop. There&rsquo;s flying, glowing jewels, floating worlds, magicians and so forth; we don&rsquo;t actually find out the full story of what she&rsquo;s written, just mere glimpses into her thoughts, but it was enough to warrant a sequel based upon the Baron due to demand from the Japanese public so they hit the right notes somewhere within their montage of magic. Smaller parts of the film also play their part to create a fantasy setting before the Baron even gets a line at about 3/4 into the movie. As Suzuku has a large imagination she often refers to fairytales when viewings her surroundings and is quick to let her ideas go wild the moment she learns of Seiji&rsquo;s name with possible Prince Charming-esque thoughts. As the main character sees magic in everything, the audience is meant to see it as well, and her innocence flows with the narrative making her a likeable lead even if she&rsquo;s a little stubborn and air-headed. On top of this; the backgrounds were created by </span><span style="mso-ansi-language: EN" lang="EN">Japanese surrealist painter Naohisa Inoue</span><span lang="EN-GB">, and the film really does take it&rsquo;s time to pan the screen, focus on the backgrounds to really show off the slightly obscure structure of the Japanese housing to give the sensation of mazes, mountains and vast lands without it actually being any of those things. Sure, you could&rsquo;ve taken off a chunk of the movie&rsquo;s running time by cutting out the longer segments of the sightseeing but then you&rsquo;d lose the mood the film is trying to put you in. At the heart of it all though, no amount of painted backgrounds or flying in the sky for a small duration of time is going to hide the fact that Whisper of the Heart isn&rsquo;t a grand adventure in the world of mythical creatures and impossibilities; the film is very much down to earth and it&rsquo;s Suzuku&rsquo;s head that brings the fantasy in but slowly grounds her into the real world once she releases some of her creative energies onto paper&nbsp;and her relationship with Seiji inspiring her. The story of growing up and falling in love is a timeless tale, and although the superficial side of the story (such as the laptop) look dated, the emotions the plot invokes never get old. </span></font><br>
<p style="margin: 0cm 0cm 10pt" class="MsoNormal"><span lang="EN-GB"><font size="2">Now let&rsquo;s get to the part that everyone has been waiting for, where we talk about the Blu-ray edition and how much better it looks now that&rsquo;s been re-released. I&rsquo;ll be honest; I know next to nothing about the technical side of HD upgrading apart from the fact that &lsquo;it looks prettier&rsquo;, but based upon what I purely saw the visuals upgrade are &ndash; like the film &ndash; subtle. The colours are brighter (giving the summer period of the film more warmth to it), the surreal backgrounds have slightly more depth, and the whole picture is faintly crisper and smoother. The animation still looks simple and its age is noticeable so whether you&rsquo;re watching it on DVD or Blu-ray isn&rsquo;t going to make a massive difference or blow you away, but if it went to those lengths to do so it wouldn&rsquo;t have complimented the film&rsquo;s tone. Both are grounded and restraint, but if you want Ghibli to look super good in HD you&rsquo;re probably better off checking out a newer release. </font></span><br>
<p style="margin: 0cm 0cm 10pt" class="MsoNormal"><span lang="EN-GB"><font size="2">The extras for the Blu-ray are very similar to the original DVD release; viewing background artwork for Baron&rsquo;s story, original storyboards, the Japanese trailers and trailers for other Studio Ghibli films available in the UK. The blu-ray also incorporates a &lsquo;Behind the Microphone&rsquo; segment that provides small interviews with the English dub cast and &lsquo;4 Masterpieces of Naohisa Inoue: From Start to Finish&rsquo; which lets you look at the artist&rsquo;s work come to life alongside music from the movie. Again, nothing that really adds much more to the experience or obviously points out the notion to spend extra on the double-play box set. </font></span><br>
<p style="margin: 0cm 0cm 10pt" class="MsoNormal"><span lang="EN-GB"><font size="3"><font face="Calibri"><font size="2" face="Arial">Whisper of the Heart is a pleasant film that captures the feeling of a young romance and why fairytales are loved so much, neatly into a cute story of a teenage girl growing up. It&rsquo;s easy to see why it&rsquo;s a beloved classic as it&rsquo;s very easy to watch and the aura surrounding it is magical, but it&rsquo;s not a recommended choice for new Ghibli fans or those who prefer a more epic story. The blu-ray edition doesn&rsquo;t really add much to the experience nor include anything major to warrant the additional charge but if you don&rsquo;t already own it, or are a collector, there&rsquo;s no reason not to pick it up.</font> <span style="mso-spacerun: yes">&nbsp;</span><span style="mso-spacerun: yes">&nbsp;</span></font></font></span><br>
<b>Final score: 7 out of 10</b>

<b>Additional screencaps</b>

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2012-01-15mimi_bd_10.png">

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2012-01-15mimi_bd_07.png">

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2012-01-15mimi_bd_08.png">
 
I personally think as a film, and as a transfer its worth a little more than 7/10, but eitherway it's a nice film and I'm definately glad to see it released as a decent transfer in the UK.

Edit:
Rereading I think perhaps my criticism on the criticism, was perhaps aimed in slightly the wrong direction. Still, I think the BD version could be considered the definitive UK release of the film, over the DVD, and as it has only just been re-released, the cost differential is worthwhile, especially compared to other BDs and re-releases on the market as a whole. The fact you actually GET an additional DVD copy for the times when you can't play the BD is also a bonus, and justifies some of the additional cost.
 
It is great to see one of my favourite Ghibli films make the transition to BD. I thought it would be a lot longer coming than this, given that we haven't even seen the likes of Spirited Away, Kiki and Totoro yet, but they seem to be being released in a very random order. Hooray for randomness!

The one thing that annoys me about this release (and previous UK releases) is Optimum's choice of cover. It's hugely misleading and accounts for a lot of the criticism I see directed at Whisper - Namely that it isn't the fantasy people were expecting; especially for new fans who tend to have seen the very fantastic titles like Spirited Away and Howl first. The idea of Suzuku as author in the real world, the fantasy being presented as exactly that and taking a back seat is one of the many things I really like about Whisper. It's very much a real world story, and the cover doesn't reflect that at all. Despite it's garishness, US cover paints a far more accurate image of what the film is about.

If those caps are really from the UK BD, it looks as though Whisper hasn't suffered from quite the amount of noise reduction applied to the other UK Ghibli releases. This didn't bother me greatly anyway as it was done with far more care on previous Ghibli releases than other films I've seen given the same treatment, but it's probably good news for a lot of potential buyers (eg: Fabio, who just beat me to posting this).
 
I actually hadn't seen the US cover before, that is a more "genuine" choice of cover art.

Review had me singing "Country Road" again, so thumbs up!
 
Whisper of the Heart is my favourite Ghibli film, so I'll definitely be picking this up.

I also agree that the U.S. cover art is better. All that needs to be done is for the title to be presented in a better font.
 
fabricatedlunatic said:
Are those screen caps of the UK version? It seems a little lighter on the DNR (i.e. there's still a fair bit of grain) than Nausicaa and Laputa, which is nice.

I don't have the capability to take screen grabs off the blu-ray disc in my home so I had to take pictures from other UK blu-ray reviews on the net, so the pictures should be genuine :)
 
honestly, everyone can say that these kind of movies are a masterpiece but i can't see myselft watching a video with a cat character and too much kiddy stuff.

Does this has any kind of mature content? What I mean is can a "20 year old something" watched this witout thinking they are seeing just kiddie stuff?

Anyway, i never saw most of the ghibli stuff until today so if I watched nowadays, i might happen to see it in the wrong time and think that they are not that great, cause they should have been seen the time they came out. I am thinking well?
 
bakum4tsu said:
honestly, everyone can say that these kind of movies are a masterpiece but i can't see myselft watching a video with a cat character and too much kiddy stuff.

Does this has any kind of mature content? What I mean is can a "20 year old something" watched this witout thinking they are seeing just kiddie stuff?

Anyway, i never saw most of the ghibli stuff until today so if I watched nowadays, i might happen to see it in the wrong time and think that they are not that great, cause they should have been seen the time they came out. I am thinking well?
Well, pretty much all of the film is a love story. The scenes with The Baron are very short; hence why the main topic here is how the front cover art is misleading.
 
bakum4tsu said:
honestly, everyone can say that these kind of movies are a masterpiece but i can't see myselft watching a video with a cat character and too much kiddy stuff.

Does this has any kind of mature content? What I mean is can a "20 year old something" watched this witout thinking they are seeing just kiddie stuff?

Anyway, i never saw most of the ghibli stuff until today so if I watched nowadays, i might happen to see it in the wrong time and think that they are not that great, cause they should have been seen the time they came out. I am thinking well?

I was in my 20's when I first saw it. I liked it then and I still like it now (currently in my last 30's).
 
bakum4tsu said:
Does this has any kind of mature content? What I mean is can a "20 year old something" watched this witout thinking they are seeing just kiddie stuff?

Anyway, i never saw most of the ghibli stuff until today so if I watched nowadays, i might happen to see it in the wrong time and think that they are not that great, cause they should have been seen the time they came out. I am thinking well?

First saw it when I was 23 (last year) and it's probably my favourite Ghibli.
The actual fantasy sections are rather small; and more of it is around the the life and also a love story about a pair of mid-teens, with some occasional humour etc. If you've seen things like Toradora and other similar romcoms, then you could probably enjoy this although it obviously has a reality-based approach, and Ghibli slant compared to the more over the top antics seen in a lot of romcoms and romantic dramas.
The fantastical section that's mentioned is actually inside one of the main characters minds as she writes a book, which is why it's far more surreal than most of the movie.

Personally, although the OP stated he thinks it looks aged (it's set in 1994), I love the sense of 'life' in the backgrounds and the world. All the backdrops and the world portrayed all look lived in, unlike the clinical, almost extra perfect, shiny world you see a lot of.
Shelves aren't stack neatly, there's boxes bunged into corners, stuffs not quite in the right place, umbrellas are left in awkward places, paint is peeling off. It feels like a real, living place, and the environments do look great in HD, regardless of the age; in fact the painted nature seems to have done it more favours than some digitally produced anime brought to HD. Honestly I really thought the OP was a little over critical, as I think the visuals have a distinct charm, and as other reviews elsewhere have pointed out, the HD transfer does bring out little details in a way that the DVD can't, such as some of the smaller details like the lights on the buildings at sunset near the end :)

Honestly, give it a try, I'd understand if you didn't like it, as you find you're not so keen on the genre or theme, but it's a cracking movie, and despite not being a usual Ghibli, it is considered one of the classics for a reason.

The film was well enough loved, that the Cat character and the fantasy world presented for just a few short minutes were given thier own film.


PPS. If anyone DOES want screenshots 100% from the UK BD version, let me know and I'll install PowerDVD and can take requested pics, if you just let me know the rough time of what you want a shot of :)

Ilmaestro said:
Review had me singing "Country Road" again, so thumbs up!

Country...or Concrete Roads :p
 
Back
Top