Review of Highschool of the Dead

christor

Kiznaiver
<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/2011-08-2219511353_500x500_1.jpg">

<b>Review of Highschool of the Dead by christor</b>

Supernatural creations are everywhere in anime and manga. Ghosts often feature, demons are dime a dozen. There are more vampires then you shake a particularly pointy stick at. Zombies, on the other hand, are conspicuous by their absence. Japanese creators have given the world some excellent zombie works in the fields of video games, such as the Resident Evil series, and live action movies such as Versus. Despite being commonplace in nearly every other form of popular culture over the last decade or so, there has been slim pickings for the anime-loving zombie fan. Enter Daisuke Sato's manga Highschool Of The Dead, first published in 2006, which was adapted into this 12 episode TV series in 2010.

This is a very rare thing; an anime whose title actually tells you what the show is about, in no uncertain times. As you may have guessed, this is an anime take on a George Romero-style zombie apocalypse, which takes place in a high school! In actual fact this doesn't quite cover it, as after a few episodes the titular school is left behind, but there's no need to go into much into detail about the plot. As is usual in these stories it follows a rag-tag band of survivors forced together as they try and escape. However, out in the real world they find that fellow survivors can be as much of a threat as the hordes of flesh-munchers. It pretty much unfolds as you would expect if you've seen a few zombie flicks, although it adds some uniquely anime-ish twists that I won't spoil for you here. The lead characters are pretty much all cookie cutter stereotypes. There's the regular Joe lead character, the class nerd and a gang of girls - every one of which is a different fanboy wish fulfilment fantasy type. There's a 'girl next door', the girl with glasses, the dark haired 'Japanese rose' type and of course the blonde bimbo. It is to the show's credit though that they do actually do a good job of making the characters likeable; they actually have just a little bit more depth to them than it first appears. It's just about enough to make you actually care what happens to them. Considering that well developed characters are hardly the top priority in a show like this, any effort made towards it, however small, is appreciated.

The animation looks pretty spectacular. It's not much of a surprise considering it's animated by the studio Madhouse, who have rarely put a foot wrong. It looks amazingly slick for a TV show, with high quality animation and beautiful backgrounds. This show could live or die on one aspect though - the zombies. Fortunate they have got them spot on. The zombies here look just right, and are a shambling delight, just as they should be; no running zombies here thank you! They look and sound like they could've been ripped straight out of a Romero movie.

Although the quieter, tenser character-based moments are not badly done, the real fun in HOTD is in the set pieces, the large scale zombie attacks. The series opens with one, providing one of the most memorable opening episodes in recent memory. There are plenty of zombie fighting action sequences all the way through, and the final episode is another highpoint. The ending, although not exactly conclusive, is satisfying, while leaving it open for more seasons. It's annoying however to know there is an extra OAV episode that is not included.

A word of caution; the episodes have a slightly unusual structure, where the story continues after the closing credits. So if you usually skip credits, then make sure you don't miss the after credits sequence in each episode, or you'll miss important plot points.

You cannot talk about this series without bringing up the matter of fan-service. From the very first episode onwards this has a dedication to it that makes almost every other show look unambitious. The female character designs are, shall we say, 'optimistic'? Every one of the female leads have ridiculous, heaving, lovingly animated bosoms. Although there is little actual nudity, no opportunity is missed to zoom in on a female character's chesticles, or especially their undergarments. Even if she's being eaten by a zombie. It's as if the 'camera' is being operated by a horny teenager. It's very strange, and the blending of sex and violence can be a little unsettling, but there's no getting round it. As such, if you really can't stand fan service then you really need to give this series a miss. However it's so (ahem) upfront about it, and it's so gleefully in-your-face it's hard to imagine anyone getting too offended by it. In fact it's hard not to think they're largely playing it for laughs, with the bouncing sound effects, and one character experiencing back problems following a boob-related incident. It's so part of the show it's difficult to ignore, so it's best to just go with it, and it's hard not to admire it's sheer audacity.

It's a shame it is so prevalent however. As its stands, HOTD is something I would recommend for any seasoned anime fan. If they had toned down the fan service, I think it would have possibly have been a classic, with real crossover potential - something you could recommend to any horror or zombie fan.

It's not fair though to penalise something for what could have been. What it is an unrelenting, ass-kicking thrill ride or a show that starts off strong and is never boring. Yes the fan service is a bit much, but with the rest of the show this good I'm willing to let it slide.

The English language release comes not via Funimation, but it is a rare UK release for a show from Sentai, the company that used to be ADV. The dub is perfectly fine, and the few lines that have obviously been added to the English script don't seem to out of place. If you've made the jump to HD, the Blu-ray version looks and sounds absolutely gorgeous, so it's definitely worth the extra cash. Whether you go for DVD or Blu-ray, this is the show that zombie loving otaku have been waiting for. Luckily it's dead good.<br>
<b>Final score: 8 out of 10</b>

<b>Additional screencaps</b>

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2011-08-22tumblr_l7e7pt0tru1qdnyc1o1_500.jpg">

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2011-08-22high-school-of-the-dead-episode-7-screenshots-12.jpg">

<img src="http://www.animeuknews.net/img/uploaded/screens/2011-08-22highschooldead_10_05x.jpg">
 
Teehee, "chesticles".

Nice review. I'm with you on the "admire the fanservice for its sheer audacity" sentiment, though it remains to be seen whether I actually love the juvenile perversion (most likely) or feel it detracts from the show's other strengths.

But those screenshots aren't from the Blu-ray, are they? Ze goggles, zey do nothing!
 
Thanks for the kind words! As for the screenshots: As my review copy was a Blu-ray I couldn't take screencaps myself, so I had to find them elsewhere. i couldn't find many decent ones. You'll just have to take my word for it that the Blu-ray picture quality is astounding I'm afraid.
 
I guess I feel kind of obliged to buy this due to my rabid love of the manga, but the anime was slightly lacking in comparison.
 
Having recently acquired a blu-ray player, I'm thinking of making this my first blu ray purchase, but I've been wondering- is it censored? I can remember seeing it being mentioned in another thread about whether things might be cut...don't really care about the fanservice, but is the gore there? Or does it keep the black out screen-o-vision? :lol:

I felt it lost steam about halfway through, but I'm a sucker for zombie related things
 
@truerred

Oh yes indeedy there is no censoring nonsense here. I would thoroughly recommend going blu for this, you will not regret it. The quality is top notch.

@ilmaestro

I've been thinking of picking up the manga, so you would say it's worth a buy then?
 
There was a time when this was on my list of 'manga they really ought to make into anime', but after it happened, I suddenly went off the idea altogether. I think the sheer amount of t&a fanservice is just too much for my jaded old mind to take.

I do have one very important question though; did they keep Simon in the anime?
 
christor said:
@truerred

Oh yes indeedy there is no censoring nonsense here. I would thoroughly recommend going blu for this, you will not regret it. The quality is top notch.

Thanks, put in a pre order for the blu ray edition a few minutes ago, so hopefully that'll turn up this week.

Was also going to finally buy the first two volumes of the manga, but between seeing they were in stock when I searched for the blu ray, and going to buy things after checking my balance the first volume's price went up :x
 
Truered said:
Was also going to finally buy the first two volumes of the manga, but between seeing they were in stock when I searched for the blu ray, and going to buy things after checking my balance the first volume's price went up :x
I'm also interested in the manga. Did you know that Yen Press are releasing a full-colour hardcover omnibus of the first four volumes in November? Not a bad price either. I might get that instead of the regular b&w volumes.
 
I was not aware of that until this moment. *bookmarks to think over*

Might go for that given everytime I go to buy them one is always out of stock, and it takes ages to return.
 
Do you guys really see having huge 700-page volumes as a "benefit" with manga though? I already think Western volumes are too physically big as it is!
 
I prefer small books so I can tuck them into my handbag and read them on the train, but my other half likes huge tomes. The big ones do seem awesome when I'm buying them but as soon as I actually read them they feel less convenient. I'm currently reading through the rerelease of Crying Freeman and it makes my [tiny] hands ache.

R
 
I didn't much like the concept of hulking monstrosities to read on the go/in bed/whatever even before I started reading eBooks, now I'm so used to them that anything bigger than the kind of small paperbacks you rarely see these days outside of the teen fiction section (and even then, more scarcely than you used to) has to really come up with a good reason to justify itself.

Art books, I will take them as large as they come. Manga, it's pretty essential to me that it is not very large at all.
 
ilmaestro said:
anything bigger than the kind of small paperbacks you rarely see these days outside of the teen fiction section has to really come up with a good reason to justify itself.
fabricatedlunatic said:
Bigger is better. man! Everyone knows that.
I never had a problem reading the Akira phone books (and can't imagine them not being so awesomely huge) so I don't envision a problem with the H.O.T.D. omnibus. As for "on the go", It's not something I'd be entirely comfortable reading in public anyway...

On topic for a moment, I am LOVING this show. Best thing I've seen all year, probably.
 
Funny y'all should be saying that. When I was doing my extended project (writing a book), I decided to keep the length small (About 250ish pages) because let's face it, the bigger a book is, the more it costs. The more it costs, the less likely someone will pick it up as a blind buy.

Also, not to mention as others have pointed out, they can be quite mean to hold.

ilmaestro said:
Do you guys really see having huge 700-page volumes as a "benefit" with manga though? I already think Western volumes are too physically big as it is!
I admit, when I accidently ordered the German version of Fairy Tail volume 3, I prefered its size to the English release.
 
It's not quite the same though. A novel is just words; this omnibus release is 700 pages of full-colour art work. Larger format (within reason of course) = more to appreciate. It's also obviously a collectors' item and not really aimed at the more casual buyer.
 
Back
Top