Completely forgot about this thread. Finished the series on Thursday, and wasn't much of a fan of the final episode. Or season, really. Mostly, the final episode... I could probably write a couple of pages worth of reasons why I didn't like the ending, and most of them are questions that could have easily been dealt with in it. The issue of them completely abandoning everything irritates me. They kept the ships under Gaius's pathetic reign on New Caprica, but now they just figure the Cylons won't come back (and obviously, stupidly, they didn't because its our reality now). I hated how they never really said what was special about the Hera. The Adama family split up! Ugh. Just didn't enjoy it after letting the finale soak in.
That being said, the finales of seasons 1, 2 and 3 are of such a high caliber, it makes it easier to forgive. I loved the season 3 finale immensely. "All Along The Watchtower" is an immense song. Season 2's ending, and its continuation into S3 is interesting and fantastic. The trial in season 3 finale was mindblowing. I just had high expectations is all.
I liked the fact that all the characters are a struggle to like, and most of their political decisions are very questionable. Starbuck was my favourite character throughout, with Gaius (and Six) in a close second. I liked some of the arguably filler episodes in the middle of each season, with a bit of focus on their relationships, and the in the earlier seasons, the stress of being in the military. I loved how the supporting characters get developed. I'm a fan of shakey-camera, so I loved that, and I also liked the high contrast colouring used. This isn't even an opinion but, the CGI is, without a doubt, the best on TV. Love love love!
I hated, however, that the Adama/Roslin relationship developed into something romantic. If they absolutely had to go down that path, though: It was handled better than I expected.. And, thinking about it, a lot of the things that happened in S4 I hate hate hated.
Looking forward to Caprica immensely, though! Thinking of watching the TV-Movie-Pilot that's been released.