Thought I'd clear a small bit of physical backlog with the shorts I picked up from the AL Christmas sale.
Pigtails and Other Short Stories
Pigtails
Was nice to look at, but the messaging seemed a bit all over the place with either being obscure or some times the visuals clashing with the voice over as with the
body parts bit where the visuals seemed to be saying look at this isn't it horrible, but the VO sounding like an ad for organ donation!
6/10
Kick-Heart
This was weird to look at, but at least the story made some sort of sense. Had some fun moments as well.
7/10
Li'l Spider Girl
Loved this one. I generally do like stuff with a supernatural theme set either in the past or modern day and this had a bit of both. As I was watching I thought this would be a cool show where
the these 2 find yokai sealed in books and find ways of exorcising them or returning them to where they belong and then
boom big twist! I guess they could still make a serious out of it: I'm a Spider Waifu, So What?
Art and animation were very good too.
8/10
Drawer Hobs
I liked this one. A SOL about an OL getting a little help from an unexpected source. The ending reminded a bit of
Labyrinth where the MC has grown, but misses the ones who helped her and then they pop up with a last goodbye and a promise to be there for her in the future.
7/10
Oval Over
Another crazy one. A cross between Redline (which came after) and Dead Leaves, from the same director which came a year earlier. Art was a little crazier than Kick-Heart, but I liked it more. The story didn't have an end, but it was an ad for real life race series, so I guess that's why it was left open at the end.
7/10
So I'd say my order is: Spider Girl, Drawer, K-H, OO and Pigtails.
Genius Party
Genius Party
A wild ride with some nice art and design and very good animation. Not sure what, if anything, it's trying to say. Something about the circle of life I think.
7/10
Shanghai Dragon
The power of imagination. Another fun ride with some funny moments in this sci-fi about finding the
saviour of the future, only for it to be a snotty kid. The CG may look a little dated now, but still pretty good. Characters remind me of Tekkonkinkreet, same studio so no surprise.
8/10
Deathtic 4
Erm, WTF! And was that Russian or a made up language? The art was quite striking, it rings a bell but I'm not sure where from, but the character designs were creepy. It was also well animated, but the story was too weird for my liking.
6/10
Doorbell
Umm, was that about
paranoid schizophrenia maybe? We got no answers as what was going on. The art wasn't the best either, the eyes especially seemed wrong in a creepy way!
5/10
Limit Cycle
Oh dear it gets worse. A load of philosophical nonsense spouted over random pictures with barely any animation at all. Rubbish.
2/10
Happy Machine
Yet more random weirdness. Art and animation are the typical Yuasa style which can be seen as good or bad depending on how out there he goes and this was pretty out there. I liked the music though.
5/10
Baby Blue
Watanabe (and Yoko Kanno) to the rescue! A bit like a more delinquent version of the first part of 5cm p/s!
7/10
Ranking: SD, BB, GP, D4, HM, DB, LC
Overall pretty disappointing collection. Seems the brief was be as weird as you want and the directors of the 2 best ones didn't get the memo! Says something that the short OP like opener was the best of the rest!
Seeing as all the shorts are lumped together on MAL (which ruins my intention of reaching 600 complete anime this week!) it's hard to give an overall score. The average is 5.7, so I'll be generous and round it up to:
6/10
Genius Party Beyond
Gala
The music of life. A nice musical piece with a fun twist at the end. My only gripe is that the number seemed to be performed by a modern orchestra rather than using the traditional instruments the characters were playing!
7/10
Moondrive
Quite random, reminded me a bit of Ren and Stimpy, but didn't stray too far into the plain weird territory like some of the shorts in the earlier collection and had quite a funny twist. The only part that was disturbing was the way they "bought" stuff!
7/10
Wanwa the Puppy
Like a drug fuelled trip through a child's nightmare and seemingly drawn in a way to suggest said child was the one doing the animation. Again weird, but not the weirdest.
6/10
Tojin Kit
Impressive 3D art and animation, seems almost contemporary and reminded me of Dorohedoro, especially the environment work. Story wise it was OK, I mean at least it had one, but left far too many questions for a short to answer. Would be interesting if it were to be expanded on.
7/10
Dimension Bomb
Everything on the technical side was fantastic, but again the story is a little obtuse. As far as I could work out
an alien is beaten badly/dies, remembers a friend and then the badly injured alien/corpse tries to get back to the place it remembered, then turns human, but the friend is gone?
Was going to say that the music was very Matrix-esque then saw that Juno Reactor were responsible for it and their music is indeed used a lot in The Matrix.
7/10
Ranking: DB, G, TK, M, WtP
Overall a better collection than the first lot, I'll give it a:
7/10
Full ranking of both here
I think the only short I've watched all day that I would definitely want more of is Li'l Spider Girl.
Talking of shorts and The Matrix, I haven't seen The Animatrix in ages, so I'm off to watch it. Will post thoughts later.